In the kaleidoscopic tapestry of New York City’s culinary scene, coal-fired pizza stands as a bold and smoky thread, woven through the neighborhoods like an artisanal melody. The allure of this pizza style lies in its crisp crust, charred edges, and a flavor profile that is both robust and nuanced. Here, we delve into ten exceptional establishments across the boroughs, each a beacon for pizza aficionados. Whether residing in Manhattan or Brooklyn, every pizza lover can find a spot that resonates with their palate.
1. John’s of Bleecker Street
Address: 278 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 243-1680
Website: johnsbrickovenpizza.com
Considered a hallowed ground for pizza enthusiasts, John’s of Bleecker Street exudes retro charm akin to a vintage jazz record. The coal-fired ovens fill the pizzeria with an intoxicating aroma, drawing patrons inside like moths to a flame. Their pie features a crisp yet pliable crust, balanced with dollops of robust tomato sauce and generous helpings of cheese.
2. Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitano
Address: 1524 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224
Contact: (718) 372-8600
Website: totonno.com
Nestled by the ocean in Coney Island, Totonno’s is akin to a time capsule, preserving traditional methods since 1924. The crust arrives at the table with a tantalizing char, reminiscent of a summer bonfire. Each bite offers a delightful crunch, culminating in the harmony of San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella.
3. L&B Spumoni Gardens
Address: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223
Contact: (718) 372-8400
Website: spumonigardens.com
Famed for its Sicilian-style pie, L&B Spumoni Gardens delivers a textured landscape of flavor. With a crisp exterior and fluffy interior, the pizza represents a delightful juxtaposition. The emphasis on fresh toppings elevates this establishment to a storied institution, appealing to the senses like a summer sunset.
4. Frank’s Pizzeria
Address: 2032 Arthur Ave, The Bronx, NY 10457
Contact: (718) 293-8530
Website: frankspizzeria.com
In the heart of the Bronx, Frank’s Pizzeria is where tradition meets enthusiasm. The coal-fired oven infuses the pizza with a flavor reminiscent of rustic Italian kitchens. Here, the pepperoni and mozzarella meld into a savory symphony, offering an experience that is warm and inviting, much like a family gathering.
5. The Coal Oven Pizza Company
Address: 626 N 5th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 388-0700
Website: thecoaloven.com
This Williamsburg gem presents coal-fired pizza as a craft, thoughtfully constructed with artisanal ingredients. The crust is a revelation—a golden, blistered masterpiece that invites toppings without overwhelming them. Each slice represents a commitment to excellence, making it a modern refuge for traditionalists.
6. Elio’s Restaurant
Address: 1621 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028
Contact: (212) 734-7474
Website: eliosnyc.com
An East Side institution, Elio’s melds fine dining with casual encounters. The pizza, kissed by coal, serves as a canvas for luxurious toppings. Custom combinations reveal Chef Elio’s flair, where each pie embodies the spirit of Italian hospitality—a celebration of taste and community.
7. NY Coal Fire Pizza
Address: 85 N 10th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249
Contact: (718) 388-7856
Website: nycoalfire.com
Residing in Brooklyn’s vibrant arts scene, NY Coal Fire Pizza transforms the humble pie into a work of art. The minimalistic décor complements the bold flavors. Each pie is fired to perfection, showcasing toppings that reflect seasonal inspirations, drawing in locals and wanderers alike.
8. Jake’s Pizza
Address: 315 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010
Contact: (212) 674-4333
Website: jakespizzany.com
Jake’s showcases the intersection of classic New York and modern interpretations. With a cozy ambiance perfect for gatherings, the coal-fired offerings dance like flames in a twilight sky. The flavors meld seamlessly, with fresh basil and spicy pepper flakes adding a zesty touch to the robust ensemble.
9. Motorino
Address: 349 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 777-2644
Website: motorinopizza.com
A pioneer in the coal-fired revolution, Motorino spins its magic with Neapolitan-style pizzas that resonate with authenticity. The oven is the heart of the kitchen, emboldening each pizza with a nostalgic essence. Unconventional toppings, including Brussels sprouts and truffle oil, add layers to a culinary narrative that captivates the palate.
10. Paulie Gee’s
Address: 60 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Contact: (347) 987-3747
Website: pauliegee.com
At Paulie Gee’s, coal-fired pizza achieves a zenith of artistry. With a focus on locally sourced ingredients, the establishment invites guests into a world where each slice embodies passion and creativity. Characterized by innovative toppings like honey and pickled peppers, the pizzas present a delectable dialogue of textures and tastes.
As you traverse the neighborhoods of New York City, these ten coal-fired establishments await to tantalize your taste buds. Each location isn’t merely about the pizza; it’s about community, tradition, and relentless pursuit of perfection. These slices serve as more than sustenance; they are experiences, crafted with care and fired with heart.
