Strawberry pie, with its luscious filling and flaky crust, evokes a nostalgia that transcends seasons. In the vibrant corridors of New York City, pie enthusiasts hanker for that perfect slice that melds the tartness of ripe strawberries with the sweetness of a buttery crust. Below is a curated list of ten delightful spots scattered across the city’s eclectic neighborhoods, where you can savor this quintessential dessert. From artisanal bakeries to cozy cafés, each locale provides a unique experience that is as tantalizing as the pies themselves.
1. Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Address: 365 Hudson Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 499-2917
Website: fourandtwentyblackbirds.com
Known for its commitment to quality and sustainability, Four & Twenty Blackbirds serves up a strawberry pie that is a seasonal triumph. The crust is crafted from organic ingredients, and the filling features incredibly fresh strawberries, making every bite a revelation. The rustic ambiance, complete with vintage decor, invites patrons to linger over their treats.
2. Little Pie Company
Address: 424 West 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 736-4780
Website: littlepiecompany.com
The Little Pie Company is a beloved institution amongst locals and tourists alike. Their strawberry pie is a delectable concoction that balances sweetness and acidity perfectly. With a flaky, hand-rolled crust and a filling that boasts fresh strawberries, this pie has made its mark in the heart of the Theatre District, appealing to theater-goers looking to indulge pre or post-show.
3. David’s Brisket House
Address: 533 LaGuardia Place, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 228-0191
Website: davidsbriskethouse.com
While primarily known for its brisket, David’s Brisket House surprises patrons with its exceptional strawberry pie. This classic dessert features a combination of tart strawberries and a hint of citrus, encased in a rich, buttery crust. A slice of this pie serves as an unanticipated treat amidst hearty sandwiches, offering diners an unexpected delight.
4. Baked
Address: 359 Van Brunt Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 222-0345
Website: bakedbrowns.com
Baked captures the essence of rustic baking with its strawberry pie that epitomizes comfort food. This beloved bakeshop crafts each pie with love, showcasing a blend of strawberries, sugar, and a touch of vanilla. The inviting atmosphere encourages bonding over shared slices, making it a perfect spot for gatherings.
5. Petee’s Pie Company
Address: 60 W 16th St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (646) 350-0992
Website: peteespies.com
Petee’s Pie Company reinvents nostalgia with each pie it creates. Their strawberry pie, a sublime treat during the summer months, showcases perfectly ripe strawberries interspersed with a touch of sugar, all encased in a flaky crust that is nothing short of perfection. Minimalist in design but maximalist in flavor, Petee’s is a haven for pie aficionados.
6. Top Pot Doughnuts
Address: 593 Columbus Avenue, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 222-0922
Website: toppotdoughnuts.com
This unique establishment pairs strawberry pie with the iconic doughnut experience. Top Pot Doughnuts offers a pie-meets-doughnut combination that is both whimsical and delicious. The strawberry filling, enhanced with a hint of lemon zest, offers a citrusy lift, while the doughnut crust provides an unexpected twist that keeps patrons coming back.
7. Magnolia Bakery
Address: 401 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 462-2572
Website: magnoliabakery.com
Magnolia Bakery is synonymous with timeless desserts, and their strawberry pie exemplifies this. Featuring a traditional crust that is both crisp and tender, it’s filled generously with juicy strawberries. Patrons can also enjoy the bakery’s charming café atmosphere, perfect for indulging in nostalgic treats while sipping coffee or tea.
8. The Pie Company
Address: 1070 5th Ave, New York, NY 10128
Contact: (212) 299-0363
Website: thepiecompany.com
Situated near Central Park, The Pie Company is a cozy enclave that radiates warmth and charm. Their strawberry pie is an artistic specimen, marrying visually stunning presentation with rich, complex flavors. The crumbles on top add an inviting crunch, crafting a textural marvel that engages with every bite.
9. Sweet Lady Jane Bakery
Address: 8875 Santa Monica Blvd, West Hollywood, NY 90069
Contact: (310) 278-3000
Website: sweetladyjane.com
At Sweet Lady Jane, exquisite presentation meets artisanal baking. Their strawberry pie captures the essence of summer with its vibrant berries and rich taste, all enveloped in a perfectly baked crust. This and the bakery’s quaint atmosphere make it a perfect spot to unwind.
10. The Smith
Address: 1900 Broadway, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 496-5500
Website: thesmithrestaurant.com
The Smith, an American Brasserie, charms visitors with its modern atmosphere and vibrant community feel. Known for its diverse menu, its strawberry pie is a delightful surprise that adds a sweet finish to every meal. It features a chewy crust with fresh strawberries, providing a gorgeous contrast of flavors.
In a city famous for its culinary diversity and gastronomic innovation, strawberry pie transcends mere dessert; it embodies tradition, warmth, and a delightful sensory experience. These ten establishments, each showcasing their unique take on this classic dish, are not only destinations for food lovers but also reflect the character of their neighborhoods. Whether you are a local or a visitor, indulging in a slice of strawberry pie at any of these locales promises a nostalgic delight—a reminder that simple pleasures are sometimes the most profound.
