Indulging in lobster mac and cheese is akin to discovering a pearl hidden within the depths of a conch shell. The creamy amalgamation of rich cheese, tender lobster, and perfectly cooked pasta creates a symphony of flavors that dance on the palate. New York City, known for its eclectic culinary scene, offers an array of dining establishments that elevate this comforting dish to a gourmet experience. Here’s a curated list of ten must-visit venues across the city, each offering a unique take on this beloved classic.
1. The Lobster Place
Address: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 255-5672
Website: lobsterplace.com
Nestled in the bustling Chelsea Market, The Lobster Place is a seafood emporium known for its freshness and variety. Their lobster mac and cheese is a revelation—a luxurious concoction featuring large chunks of sweet lobster folded into a velvety three-cheese blend. The addition of panko breadcrumbs adds an exquisite crunch, making each bite a delightful contrast of textures.
2. Pearl Oyster Bar
Address: 18 Cornelia St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 691-8200
Website: pearloysterbar.com
At Pearl Oyster Bar, the traditional meets the innovative. Their lobster mac and cheese arrives baked in an elegant ramekin, encasing creamy pasta interspersed with substantial lobster chunks. This dish is a testament to the restaurant’s beachy New England roots, and the sprinkle of herbs on top whispers of summer vacations by the seaside.
3. Luke’s Lobster
Address: 2 Mott St, New York, NY 10013
Contact: (212) 343-3033
Website: lukeslobster.com
Luke’s Lobster is a homage to the simplicity of coastal cuisine. Their lobster mac and cheese offers a heartfelt embrace of flavors, featuring chunks of lobster tail mingling with a silky cheese sauce. Prepared with care, this dish is reminiscent of cozy family meals around the dinner table, making it perfect for a casual yet fulfilling dining experience.
4. Schiller’s Liquor Bar
Address: 131 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 260-4555
Website: schillersny.com
Schiller’s Liquor Bar, with its vintage charm, serves lobster mac and cheese that feels like a warm embrace on a chilly night. (The rich Gruyère and aged cheddar create a delightful harmony.) Each forkful transports patrons straight to comfort; you can’t help but smile, reminiscent of a nostalgic culinary embrace that invokes memories of cozy gatherings.
5. The Smith
Address: 1900 Broadway, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 496-5500
Website: thesmithnyc.com
The Smith is an iconic American brasserie that serves a sophisticated twist on the classic comfort food. Their lobster mac and cheese is crafted with a creamy blend of cheeses and succulent lobster, topped with a golden crust. The inviting atmosphere of The Smith enhances the dining experience, making it an ideal spot for both celebratory dinners and casual meet-ups.
6. Red Rooster Harlem
Address: 310 Lenox Ave, New York, NY 10027
Contact: (212) 792-9001
Website: redroosterharlem.com
At Red Rooster Harlem, the essence of comfort food takes on a southern flair. Their lobster mac and cheese is a whimsical celebration of flavors, featuring smoked cheese and a touch of spice. This dish is not just about taste; it embodies the spirit of community and family, capturing the heart of Harlem’s rich cultural landscape.
7. Bistro Pierre Lapin
Address: 1110 1st Ave, New York, NY 10065
Contact: (646) 490-8550
Website: bistropierrelapin.com
Bistro Pierre Lapin is a quaint neighborhood gem that serves classic French cuisine with a whimsical twist. Their version of lobster mac and cheese incorporates unique French cheeses, offering a luxurious taste that tantalizes the senses. Served with a side of artisanal bread, it invokes images of Parisian bistros and garden picnics, elevating the dining experience to sheer elegance.
8. Lure Fishbar
Address: 142 Mercer St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 431-2500
Website: lurefishbar.com
Lure Fishbar is a seafood lover’s paradise, and their lobster mac and cheese is a standout item. With its bold flavors and generous portions, this dish is comfort food reimagined. The innovative use of Fontina cheese and a hint of truffle oil marries luxury with satisfaction, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and flavor.
9. City Island Lobster House
Address: 691 Bridge St, Bronx, NY 10464
Contact: (718) 885-2020
Website: cityislandlobsterhouse.com
City Island Lobster House, an off-the-beaten-path treasure, offers a no-frills dining experience with an oceanfront view. Their lobster mac and cheese is hearty and satisfying, featuring a buttery sauce that pays homage to traditional cooking methods. Dining here feels like a day at the beach, where the waves whisper and the food warms the soul.
10. Jacob’s Pickles
Address: 509 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 580-1900
Website: jacobspickles.com
Last but not least, Jacob’s Pickles unites Southern comfort with seafood finesse. Their lobster mac and cheese is rich and indulgent, boasting a delightful mix of cheeses with crispy, fried lobster tails resting atop. This dish encapsulates warmth and hospitality, providing diners with an unparalleled experience that simply envelops you with joy.
The journey through these ten establishments is not just a taste adventure but a delightful exploration of the art of lobster mac and cheese. Each restaurant offers its distinctive flavor profile and atmosphere, ensuring that this beloved dish is reimagined and experienced in myriad ways throughout the vibrant neighborhoods of New York City.
