New York City, a culinary tapestry woven from countless cultures, is renowned for its diverse food offerings. Among the city’s many delights, the hoagie stands out, a sub sandwich that has won the hearts and appetites of New Yorkers. But with so many options, how does one select the best hoagie trays for gatherings, parties, or even a sumptuous feast for one? Fear not; this article unveils ten exceptional hoagie trays across various neighborhoods, showcasing their addresses, contact information, and websites. Together, we’ll embark on a delightful gastronomic journey, all while posing a playful challenge at the end: can you resist sampling these delectable creations?
1. Di Fara Pizza
Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230
Contact: (718) 258-1367
Website: www.difarapizza.com
At Di Fara, renowned for its pizza, the hoagie trays are equally spectacular. Loaded with fresh ingredients, these artisanal hoagies exude excellence. Each tray, adorned with an array of meats, cheeses, and locally sourced veggies, not only tantalizes the palate but also caters to all tastes.
2. Sarabeth’s
Address: 40 Central Park S, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 826-5959
Website: www.sarabethsrestaurants.com
A quintessential New York establishment, Sarabeth’s offers a variety of gourmet hoagie trays. Ideal for brunch or a laid-back lunch, their hoagies feature premium fillings, artisanal bread, and a unique twist on classics that will impress any gathering.
3. Lenny’s Deli
Address: 1726 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128
Contact: (212) 879-1020
Website: www.lennysdeli.com
Lenny’s Deli specializes in New York-style deli fare, and their hoagie trays are no exception. Featuring a robust selection of meats and cheeses nestled in freshly baked bread, their milano-inspired hoagies offer a gourmet experience. Whether for a corporate event or a casual get-together, they deliver satisfaction.
4. Jimmy’s No. 43
Address: 43 E 7th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 388-0325
Website: www.jimmysno43.com
Known for its commitment to sustainability, Jimmy’s No. 43 serves up irresistible hoagies with locally sourced ingredients. Their seasonal trays hold tantalizing combinations, accommodating vegetarians and carnivores alike. This hoagie experience is a beacon for conscientious food lovers.
5. Faicco’s Italian Specialties
Address: 260 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 255-4530
Website: www.faiccos.com
A family-owned establishment steeped in Italian tradition, Faicco’s is a must-visit for authentic hoagies. Their deli case brims with homemade meats and cheeses, making each hoagie tray a feast for the eyes and palate. It’s a true Italian-American experience in Greenwich Village.
6. Halsey’s
Address: 825 N 7th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 384-0808
Website: www.halseys.com
Halsey’s offers an array of creative hoagie trays that are a visual delight. Their vibrant colors and bold flavors reveal a culinary artistry that appeals to both traditionalists and adventurers. Dive into the fusion of fillings and savor the delectable contrast that each tray promises to deliver.
7. The Meatball Shop
Address: 84 Stanton St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 982-4890
Website: www.themeatballshop.com
Not just about meatballs, The Meatball Shop excels in putting together inventive hoagie trays. Each hoagie is a culinary canvas, with toppings that range from classic to quirky. Their playful approach means each tray is a delightful surprise, perfect for any occasion—including the unexpected!
8. Katz’s Delicatessen
Address: 205 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 254-2246
Website: www.katzdeli.com
A storied institution, Katz’s is famous for its pastrami. The hoagie trays offer a superb selection of classic deli favorites, layered with thick slices of meats. The distinctive flavors and textures make this a legendary choice, invoking nostalgia with every bite.
9. Salumeria Biellese
Address: 600 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 255-1700
Website: www.salumeriabiellese.com
Dedicated to an artisanal approach, Salumeria Biellese crafts exquisite hoagie trays featuring cured meats and gourmet cheeses. Each tray reflects a commitment to quality and taste, showcasing the best of Italian charcuterie in every delicious bite.
10. The New York Deli
Address: 1237 Broadway, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (646) 504-5242
Website: www.thenewyorkdeli.com
With a no-nonsense approach to deli fare, The New York Deli offers straightforward yet scrumptious hoagie trays. Each selection is freshly prepared, perfect for dining in or taking out. For those seeking comfort food, this deli epitomizes the essence of a satisfying hoagie.
As you contemplate the flavors, textures, and vibrant character of these ten fabulous hoagie trays, the ultimate question lingers: can you conquer the challenge of choosing just one? With such diverse offerings nestled in the neighborhoods of New York City, the pursuit of the perfect hoagie is as delicious as the journey itself. So gather your friends, pick a tray, and prepare for a hasty race to taste them all; after all, why not indulge a little? Happy hoagie hunting!
