New York City, a bustling metropolis and melting pot of cultures, is known for its diverse culinary offerings. Among the city’s hidden gems, fresh crab legs stand out as a delectable seafood delight, showcasing the rich aquatic bounty the oceans have to offer. This guide takes you through ten remarkable establishments that serve exquisite crab legs, each offering a unique dining experience. Explore the places below, and prepare to tantalize your taste buds.
1. The Oyster Bar
Address: 849 Eighth Avenue, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 245-2020
Website: www.oysterbarnyc.com
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, The Oyster Bar presents a vintage charm reminiscent of the Golden Age of seafood gastronomy. Their fresh crab legs are often served chilled with an artisanal cocktail sauce, bringing out the delicate sweetness of the crustacean. The ambiance is enhanced by the soothing sounds of the subway echoing in the background, making it a uniquely New York experience.
2. City Island Lobster House
Address: 691 City Island Avenue, Bronx, NY 10464
Contact: (718) 885-1600
Website: www.cityislandlobsterhouse.com
For a taste of New England on the shores of the Bronx, City Island Lobster House is the quintessential stop. Their succulent crab legs can be savored in a variety of preparations—from steamed to seasoned with Old Bay. The nautical theme, adorned with model boats and fishing nets, perfectly complements the freshness of the dishes served here.
3. Luke’s Lobster
Address: 609 West 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (646) 244-6121
Website: www.lukeslobster.com
This eatery provides a casual yet chic environment to enjoy the delicacies of the sea. Luke’s Lobster is renowned for its sustainable seafood, and their crab legs are no exception. Expertly crafted lobster rolls and crab rolls are must-tries, but a side of warm crab legs elevates the experience, leaving patrons feeling both full and satisfied.
4. Grand Central Oyster Bar & Restaurant
Address: 89 E 42nd St, New York, NY 10017
Contact: (212) 490-6650
Website: www.oysterbarnyc.com
A historic gem located beneath the iconic Grand Central Terminal, this venerable establishment has been serving fresh seafood since 1913. The crab legs here come served on ice, ensuring maximum freshness, and patrons can enjoy them with house-made dipping sauces. The ambiance is infused with a sense of nostalgia, as travelers and locals alike gather to indulge in maritime fare.
5. Crustacean
Address: 172 E 56th St, New York, NY 10022
Contact: (212) 751-0200
Website: www.crustacean.com
This elegant restaurant takes a sophisticated approach to seafood dining. Crustacean is popular for its garlic noodles but also shines when it comes to crab legs. Often prepared with various spices and served alongside delectable sides, the experience here is elevated, perfect for a romantic dinner or special occasion.
6. Seamore’s
Address: 178 Avenue B, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (646) 882-4000
Website: www.seamores.com
Seamore’s champions sustainable seafood, offering fresh crab legs within a cozy and inviting space. Their commitment to quality shines through in every bite, with flavors that pop and leave a lasting impression. The laid-back atmosphere invites conversation, making it a great place for gatherings with family and friends.
7. Pearl Oyster Bar
Address: 18 Cornelia St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 691-8211
Website: www.pearloysterbar.com
Pearl Oyster Bar is known for its east-coast charm; a quaint, unpretentious atmosphere welcomes seafood lovers craving fresh crab legs. Here, guests can find a delightful, creamy crab bisque in addition to perfectly steamed crab legs, allowing for a savory exploration of textures and flavors. The minimalist decor reinforces the focus on the food.
8. The Crab Shack
Address: 40-16 30th Ave, Astoria, NY 11103
Contact: (718) 729-3939
Website: www.crabshack.com
A haven for seafood enthusiasts, The Crab Shack specializes in a casual dining experience. Their crab legs are served in buckets, often coated with deliciously bold seasonings that mirror Southern-inspired cuisine. The lively atmosphere and vibrant decor foster a sense of community, ideal for enjoying shared platters with friends.
9. The Boil
Address: 1215 Indian Road, New York, NY 10034
Contact: (212) 567-8300
Website: www.theboilny.com
At The Boil, the focus is on casual dining with an adventurous twist. Their crab legs are bathed in bold sauces that highlight unique flavors, allowing diners to create a customizable seafood experience. The fun, vibrant location is complemented by friendly staff, making for an unforgettable evening.
10. Joe’s Stone Crab
Address: 27 Washington St, New York, NY 10004
Contact: (212) 688-1895
Website: www.joesstonecrab.com
A branch of the famous Miami original, Joe’s Stone Crab is synonymous with lavish seafood dining. Known for its stone crab, it also serves delicious crab legs, typically accompanied by their signature mustard sauce. The posh atmosphere and attentive service make it an ideal spot for a festive dinner or celebration.
From the historic charm of Grand Central to the coastal vibes on City Island, these ten establishments reflect the diverse culinary landscape of fresh crab legs around New York City. Whether you are seeking a casual bite or an elaborate feast, each restaurant offers its own unique take on this culinary delight. Explore these neighborhoods and indulge in the aquatic treasures they present, creating gastronomic memories that resonate long after the last bite.
