For culinary enthusiasts and casual diners alike, cotijas, or Mexican-style cheese dishes, offer a delightful glimpse into the heart of vibrant Mexican cuisine. In the bustling city of New York, where diverse neighborhoods converge flavor, cotijas can be found in various forms—from heartwarming street food to gourmet offerings. Here’s a guide to ten exceptional cotijas you can savor across different neighborhoods in the Big Apple, showcasing the unique profiles and culinary creativity that await you.
1. La Esquina
Address: 114 Kenmare St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (646) 613-7100
Website: www.esquinanyc.com
Nestled in Nolita, La Esquina boasts a charming vibe that captures the essence of a Mexican taqueria. Their cotija elote (corn on the cob) is a must-try, generously slathered with chipotle mayo and sprinkled with crumbled cotija cheese. The restaurant’s ambiance, adorned with bricked walls and vintage décor, enhances the entire dining experience.
2. Mercado Mexican Grill
Address: 257 E 52nd St, New York, NY 10022
Contact: (212) 583-1000
Website: www.mercadonyc.com
Located in Midtown East, Mercado Mexican Grill offers a contemporary twist on traditional fare. Their cotija tacos, filled with sizzling carne asada and topped with fresh pico de gallo and cotija, are a gourmet delight. With an eclectic modern setting, this venue is ideal for both work lunches and evening gatherings.
3. Dos Toros Taqueria
Address: 467 E 18th St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 388-0083
Website: www.dostoros.com
With several locations scattered through the city, Dos Toros Taqueria remains a favorite for its focus on fresh ingredients. The cotija burrito features succulent grilled chicken surrounded by vibrant, zesty salsa and creamy guacamole, all complemented by a sprinkle of cotija. Fans love the lively, casual atmosphere that invites both friends and families.
4. Casa Enrique
Address: 5-48 49th Ave, Long Island City, NY 11101
Contact: (718) 752-2000
Website: www.casaenriquenyc.com
In Long Island City, Casa Enrique holds a Michelin star that speaks to its culinary prowess. The cotija-stuffed poblano pepper enchiladas are a culinary revelation—smoky, bold, and beautifully presented. The décor mirrors the authenticity of their dishes, offering a cozy environment that feels like a home away from home.
5. Taco Mix
Address: 18604 Horace Harding Expy, Fresh Meadows, NY 11365
Contact: (718) 380-1200
Website: www.tacomixny.com
For those venturing to Fresh Meadows, Taco Mix brings a casual yet stellar dining option. The elote here is incredibly popular, showcasing grilled corn topped with a trio of ingredients—you guessed it: cotija, lime, and chili powder. The vibrant atmosphere draws in crowds, making it a perfect spot to revel in the lively energy of the city.
6. Taqueria Al Pastor
Address: 456 10th Ave, New York, NY 10018
Contact: (646) 559-9467
Website: www.taqueriaalpastor.com
Located in the ever-bustling Hudson Yards, Taqueria Al Pastor offers inventive takes on classic recipes. Their cotija quesadilla is irresistibly gooey, presenting a sumptuous filling of cheese alongside the option of tender pork or chicken. The modern, sleek design attracts trendy city dwellers and foodies alike.
7. Los Tacos No. 1
Address: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (646) 586-4182
Website: www.lostacos1.com
With a minimalistic approach to its offerings, Los Tacos No. 1 excels in delivering authentic Mexican street food. The cotija atop their carne asada tacos creates an alluring contrast of salty and savory that’s gratifyingly delicious. Situated in Chelsea Market, it’s an ideal stop for food enthusiasts exploring the area.
8. TaquerÃa Tlayuda
Address: 208 8th Ave, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (646) 741-3239
Website: www.taqueriatlayuda.com
In the heart of the West Village, TaquerÃa Tlayuda offers a unique Oaxacan flair. Their signature dish, tlayuda with cotija, is a massive, crispy tortilla topped with beans, meats, and an impressive layer of fresh cotija. The understated, rustic charm of the eatery invites patrons to sit back and enjoy an authentic dining experience.
9. El Centro NYC
Address: 825 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 757-5555
Website: www.elcentronyc.com
For those in Hell’s Kitchen, El Centro NYC combines a modern Mexican twist with traditional ingredients. Their delicious chili con queso, generously topped with cotija cheese, is a highlight that pairs seamlessly with their signature margaritas. It’s the perfect venue for social gatherings or after-work hangouts.
10. Los Fridos
Address: 349 E 6th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (646) 726-4965
Website: www.losfridosnyc.com
Located in the East Village, Los Fridos showcases a colorful ambience that complements their eclectic menu. Their cotija-stuffed jalapeños are a standout appetizer, bursting with flavor and heat, providing a perfect start to any meal. The vibrant art and local community feel enhance the dining experience, making it a cherished local spot.
New York City’s diverse neighborhoods are a canvas of flavors and culinary experiences. Each of these cotijas represents not only the rich tapestry of Mexican cuisine but also the innovative spirit of the city’s dining scene. Whether you’re a long-time fan of Mexican food or a curious newcomer, exploring these flavorful gems will surely leave you with a deeper appreciation for cotijas. Embrace the adventure that awaits on your culinary journey through the streets of this magnificent city.
