In the bustling metropolis of New York City, where dreams are woven into the fabric of everyday life, few culinary delights rival the warm embrace of a skillet cookie. These delectable desserts, baked in their own cast-iron pan, offer a crisp exterior and a gooey, molten core that evokes nostalgia and comfort. As you traverse the city’s vibrant neighborhoods, each infused with its own unique character, you will discover an array of cozy spots serving up this sweet indulgence. Here, we present ten must-visit locations where skillet cookies reign supreme, each offering a unique twist that makes them architecturally delicious.
1. H&H Bagels & Cookies
Address: 1841 Broadway, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 724-1000
Website: hhbagels.com
In the heart of Manhattan, H&H Bagels has long been a stalwart in the culinary landscape. However, their skillet cookie, a chewy marriage of chocolate and caramel that oozes irresistible sweetness, is nothing short of a culinary revelation. Resplendent atop a sturdy skillet, each bite radiates warmth like a cozy hug on a chilly New York day.
2. Milk Bar
Address: 251 E 13th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (646) 201-4060
Website: milkbarstore.com
Milk Bar is an homage to the childhood desserts that shaped our gastronomical identities. Here, the “Compost Cookie,” baked in a skillet, introduces a riot of flavors—think pretzels, potato chips, and chocolate chips all melodiously coalesce. Each bite is a surprising adventure; a veritable symphony of textures that dance delightfully on your palate.
3. Baked by Melissa
Address: 134 Grand St, New York, NY 10013
Contact: (212) 921-9494
Website: bakedbymelissa.com
Known for their mini cupcakes, Baked by Melissa has ventured beyond the realm of petite pastries. Their signature skillet cookie, luxuriously adorned with frosting and sprinkles, is a runway- ready dessert that dazzles the eye as much as it gratifies the soul. Each mouthful is an explosion of festive joy, inviting you to relish the moment.
4. The Crushed Ice Company
Address: 140 W 20th St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 255-5555
Website: crushedicecompany.com
In the vibrant Chelsea neighborhood, The Crushed Ice Company is where innovation meets tradition. Their salted caramel skillet cookie is a glorious concoction, whereby the sweet melding of gooey caramel and the slightest hint of salt creates a beautiful juxtaposition—a flavor profile that surprises and delights with every spoonful.
5. Schmackary’s
Address: 362 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (646) 762-4004
Website: schmackarys.com
For a theatrical experience in Times Square, look no further than Schmackary’s. Their “Skillet S’mores Cookie” calls to the inner child in all of us, inviting nostalgic memories around the campfire. With melty chocolate and toasted marshmallows enveloped in a warm, buttery shell, this skillet cookie transports you to summer nights, regardless of the season.
6. The Doughnuttery
Address: 90 West St, New York, NY 10006
Contact: (646) 334-0568
Website: thedoughnuttery.com
The Doughnuttery, nestled in the Financial District, transcends the conventional narrative of a bakery. Their unique skillet cookie, aptly named “Maple Bacon,” introduces a savory element that is both unexpected and delightful. The harmonious blend of maple syrup and crispy bacon undertones dances on the palate, redefining what we thought we knew about dessert.
7. Warm and Fuzzy Cookies
Address: 8 E 36th St, New York, NY 10016
Contact: (332) 209-2294
Website: warmandfuzzycookies.com
True to its name, Warm and Fuzzy Cookies offer desserts designed to elicit comfort and joy. Their renowned skillet cookie, infused with Nutella, is reminiscent of a warm embrace, each bite delivering a sweet warmth that envelops you like a favorite blanket on a cold day.
8. Oak & Fig
Address: 100 W 10th St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (646) 757-2030
Website: oakandfig.com
In the West Village, Oak & Fig offers a sophisticated twist on the classic skillet cookie. Their “Lavender Honey” variant is an exquisite fusion of aromatic flavors, showcasing the elegance of culinary art. The subtle floral notes marry beautifully with rich chocolate, offering a dessert experience that is truly enchanting.
9. Dough
Address: 199 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (646) 964-0537
Website: doughdoughnuts.com
Dough, an establishment revered for its artisan doughnuts, surprises with its decadent skillet cookie. Their “Chocolate Chip with Sea Salt” pairs the classic with a pinch of gourmet elegance, transforming humble ingredients into a luxurious moment. Its mesmerizing crisp edge yields to a lava-like center, ensuring every forkful is a joyous occasion.
10. Little Cupcake Bakeshop
Address: 30 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 675-4684
Website: littlecupcakebakeshop.com
In Nolita, Little Cupcake Bakeshop serves a petite skillet cookie that exemplifies the notion of “less is more.” Their “Vegan Chocolate Chip” variant manages to pack flavor into every delicious bite while accommodating dietary preferences. A testament to culinary innovation, it captures the essence of indulgence without regret.
As you meander through the enchanting neighborhoods of New York City, let the rich and diverse selections of skillet cookies invigorate your senses and satisfy your cravings. Each establishment is a destination in its own right, adorned with its unique flavor narratives that beckon both locals and travelers alike. So take a pause amidst the city’s hustle and bustle; savor the sweetness that awaits you in these culinary havens, where every skillet cookie is a story waiting to be tasted.
