New York City is a veritable melting pot of cultures, and this diversity extends delightfully into its culinary scene. Among the plethora of gourmet offerings, goat cheese stands out not just for its creamy texture and tangy flavor but also for its versatility in various culinary applications. From artisanal cheesemakers to quaint little shops, the Big Apple has embraced goat cheese with open arms. This detailed guide explores ten exceptional establishments across New York neighborhoods where goat cheese reigns supreme. Each location promises not only delectable products but also a memorable experience. Let’s embark on this flavorful journey!
1. Murray’s Cheese
Address: 254 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 924-5780
Website: www.murrayscheese.com
Nestled in the heart of Greenwich Village, Murray’s Cheese is a haven for cheese aficionados. Renowned for its extensive selection of artisanal cheeses, including an exquisite array of goat cheeses, this shop offers tasting events and guided cheese tours. A particular favorite is the “Cypress Grove Goat Cheese,” which captivates with its rich, earthy notes.
2. Beecher’s Handmade Cheese
Address: 900 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 691-2000
Website: www.beechershandmadecheese.com
At Beecher’s, cheese is crafted right before your eyes, making for an educational and sensory experience. Their “Flagship” goat cheese blends beautiful creaminess with barnyard flavors, embodying the essence of artisanal technique. Don’t leave without trying their famed mac and cheese, featuring a hint of goat cheese for an unexpected twist.
3. Saxelby Cheesemongers
Address: 120 C Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 982-9292
Website: www.saxelbycheese.com
Located in the bustling Essex Market, Saxelby Cheesemongers specializes in American artisanal cheeses. Goat cheese lovers will revel in their selection, particularly the “Crown Finish Caves Goat Gouda,” which offers a unique smoky flavor balance. The knowledgeable staff is always eager to provide recommendations tailored to guests’ preferences.
4. Astoria Cheese & Meats
Address: 34-14 30th Ave, Astoria, NY 11103
Contact: (718) 545-2746
Website: www.astoriacheeseandmeats.com
Astoria has a gem in Astoria Cheese & Meats, where you can explore an eclectic assortment of foreign and domestic cheeses. Their goat cheese collection is particularly impressive, featuring the “Chevre Noir,” a striking black-coated goat cheese that enchants both the eyes and palate. The rustic atmosphere combined with knowledgeable staff makes this an engaging stop.
5. Stinky Brooklyn
Address: 215 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 643-2110
Website: www.stinkybklyn.com
As the name suggests, Stinky Brooklyn offers an array of pungent and flavorful cheeses that intrigue the senses. Their goat cheese selection, particularly the “Mellow Fellow,” is both creamy and delicious, making it a delightful addition to any cheese platter. The store also emphasizes collaboration with local artisans, ensuring freshness and innovation.
6. Consider Bardwell Farm
Address: 1100 Hulett Rd, West Pawlet, VT 05775 (available at local markets)
Contact: (802) 645-1985
Website: www.considerbardwellfarm.com
Although located in Vermont, Consider Bardwell Farm products are a coveted find in various New York City markets. Their award-winning goat cheeses, especially the “Mettowee,” an aged raw milk goat cheese, offer a stunning complexity and are often found at specialty shops and farmers’ markets throughout NYC.
7. The Cheese Shop at the French Culinary Institute
Address: 462 Broadway, New York, NY 10013
Contact: (212) 219-8890
Website: www.fci.edu
Immersed in culinary excellence, the Cheese Shop at the French Culinary Institute boasts a fine selection of artisanal cheeses. The goat cheese offerings here are expertly curated, including the delicate “Chèvre Biologique,” which promises a silky mouthfeel—perfect for spreading on freshly baked breads or pairing with local honey.
8. Whole Foods Market – Bowery
Address: 95 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 420-1320
Website: www.wholefoodsmarket.com
Whole Foods Market on the Bowery is more than just a grocery store; it’s a destination for organic and high-quality products. Their cheese department features an impressive assortment of goat cheeses, including the “Cypress Grove Lil’ Goat,” which offers a burst of zest, perfect for elevating salads or pasta dishes. Browse with curiosity and engage with their knowledgeable cheese mongers who often share new trends and pairings.
9. The Bedford Cheese Shop
Address: 191 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 782-1266
Website: www.bedfordcheeseshop.com
The Bedford Cheese Shop is a cozy enclave for cheese lovers in Williamsburg. Their goat cheese selection is profound, with artisanal varieties sourced from both local and international producers. The “Garrotxa,” a semi-firm goat cheese with nutty undertones, has garnered acclaim and is often featured on their curated cheese boards.
10. Fage Greek Yogurt & Cheese
Address: 148 Park Ave, New York, NY 10007
Contact: (212) 382-0070
Website: www.fage.com
Fage is famously known for its yogurt, but their fresh goat cheese is often overshadowed. Rich and creamy, Fage goat cheese can add a delightful twist to both savory and sweet dishes. Try it atop fresh fruit similar to how one would serve ricotta for an exquisite taste experience.
This exploration of New York’s goat cheese landscape reveals an enticing array of flavors, textures, and culinary uses, inviting both connoisseurs and novices to expand their palates. The commitment to quality and craftsmanship in these establishments promises not only satisfying taste but also a deeper appreciation for the artistry of cheesemaking. Whether you’re in search of a simple cheese to elevate your next meal or a unique variety to impress your guests, these ten destinations offer boundless possibilities. Embrace the journey and let curiosity fuel your exploration of goat cheese in the city that never sleeps.
