When it comes to culinary delights, the iconic steak sub holds a revered position, captivating the hearts of food enthusiasts across the diverse neighborhoods of New York City. The marriage of juicy, succulent steak, layered with fresh toppings and nestled within a crusty roll, evokes a visceral response, a celebration of simplicity and flavor. Here, we delve into ten of the best steak subs in New York, offering not just addresses but a glimpse into the culinary craftsmanship that makes these sandwiches stand out.
1. Joe’s Pizza & Subs
Address: 1134 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10065
Contact: (212) 355-5566
Website: joespizzaandsubs.com
Located in the heart of the Upper East Side, Joe’s Pizza & Subs epitomizes the classic sub experience. The steak sub is a great choice here, bursting with juicy ribeye, perfectly grilled onions, and other toppings tailored to your preference. The nostalgic atmosphere and friendly service further enhance its charm, making it a local favorite and a must-visit for enthusiasts.
2. Sonny’s Steak & Chops
Address: 18 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 921-7450
Website: sonnyssteakandchops.com
Nestled amidst the bustling Midtown, Sonny’s is an oasis for those seeking culinary fulfillment. Known for their marinated flank steak, the sub is adorned with a luscious combination of melted cheese and sautéed mushrooms. Each bite offers a harmonious balance between savory and rich, creating an undeniably indulgent experience.
3. The Steak House
Address: 250 W 57th St, New York, NY 10107
Contact: (212) 586-1500
Website: thesteakhouse.com
A veritable institution in the Theater District, The Steak House delivers excellence through each crusty roll packed with prime steak. They offer a variety of toppings, allowing patrons to customize their steak sub as desired. The ambiance steeped in theatre artistry lays the backdrop for a meal that transports diners from the ordinary to the extraordinary.
4. Chicago’s Original Italian Beef
Address: 1750 Steinway St, Astoria, NY 11105
Contact: (718) 472-2200
Website: chicagositalianbeef.com
This Astoria gem brings a slice of Chicago’s culinary legacy to New York with their standout steak sub. Featuring tender beef, peppers, and a unique seasoning blend, it’s a perfect representation of the comfort food genre. The inviting atmosphere and a nod to Midwestern culinary traditions highlight the cultural tapestry of this borough.
5. The Meatball Shop
Address: 84 Stanton St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (646) 483-6340
Website: themeatballshop.com
The Meatball Shop, while famed for its inventive meatballs, surprises patrons with its scrumptious steak sub. The unique twist features house-made steak meatballs, harmonized with fresh toppings and a robust sauce that keeps diners coming back for more. The quirky vibe enhances the overall dining experience, resonating with locals and visitors alike.
6. Fette Sau
Address: 354 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 963-3404
Website: fettesaubbq.com
A standout in the Williamsburg area, Fette Sau uniquely combines barbecue with the quintessential steak sub format. The smoky, tender steak is layered with a tangy sauce and luscious toppings, presenting a palate-pleasing contradiction of flavors. The rustic decor adds to the charm, making it a desired spot for those searching for an authentic taste experience.
7. Italian Village
Address: 32 E 63rd St, New York, NY 10065
Contact: (212) 772-2222
Website: italianvillagenyc.com
Italian Village provides a step into a world where classic Italian meets sub sandwiches. With impeccably seasoned skirt steak, their steak sub embodies the very essence of New York’s eclectic food scene. The relaxed yet sophisticated ambiance enhances the enjoyment, inviting diners to relish every moment spent here.
8. Crusty’s Pizza & Deli
Address: 154 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205
Contact: (718) 797-1111
Website: crustyspizzadeli.com
This unassuming deli in Clinton Hill charms with its simple yet flavorful offerings. Their steak sub is coupled with fresh veggies and a signature sauce that elevates the dish. The friendly service and neighborhood feel create a welcoming atmosphere that invites patrons to linger, enhancing the overall dining experience.
9. Mad Beef
Address: 389 E 149th St, Bronx, NY 10455
Contact: (718) 665-2266
Website: madbeef.com
In the vibrant heart of the Bronx, Mad Beef offers a steak sub that resonates with locals. The tender beef is cooked to perfection and paired seamlessly with fresh ingredients. Known for its no-frills approach and rich flavors, it captures the essence of homegrown culinary delights, making it a treasured establishment.
10. Foundry’s
Address: 1222 1st Ave, New York, NY 10065
Contact: (212) 207-2054
Website: foundrys.com
Finally, Foundry’s stands out for its innovative take on the classic steak sub, integrating gourmet elements with traditional ingredients. The marbling of their high-quality steak sets the stage for a delectable experience, coupled with an intimate setting that encourages conversation and connection. It serves as a reminder of how food can cultivate community.
Each of these establishments not only excels in delivering exceptional steak subs but also showcases the rich tapestry of New York’s diverse culinary landscape. As you embark on your steak sub journey through the city, expect to encounter vibrant neighborhoods, unique settings, and stories woven into each bite. Whether you are a lifelong resident or a curious traveler, New York’s steak sub scene is an adventure worth savoring.
