New York City, an epicenter of cultural diversity, also boasts an illustrious pizza culture that tantalizes the senses and soothes the soul. Each neighborhood showcases its unique interpretation of this beloved dish, transforming mere dough and toppings into an art form. Here’s a guide to the ten best pizzerias, each representing the quintessential flavors of their respective neighborhoods. Prepare yourself for a tour de force of flavor that prompts a delightful shift in perspective and piques your curiosity about what each bite can offer.
1. Di Fara Pizza
Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230
Contact: (718) 258-1367
Website: difarapizza.com
Revered among pizza aficionados, Di Fara Pizza exemplifies the Brooklyn spirit. Master pizzaiolo Dom DeMarco has cultivated the art of pizza for over five decades, perfecting the quintessential New York slice. Handcrafted from the finest ingredients, every pie here is a testament to his passion. A slice from Di Fara is a pilgrimage every pizza lover must undertake.
2. Joe’s Pizza
Address: 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 255-3946
Website: joespizza.com
Step into Joe’s Pizza, nestled in Greenwich Village, and revel in the ambiance of the quintessential New York pizzeria. Known for its classic cheese slices, the hand-tossed crust, topped with a delicately balanced tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella, transports customers to pizza paradise. The establishment has managed to remain timeless, captivating both locals and tourists alike.
3. Prince Street Pizza
Address: 27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 228-2954
Website: princestreetpizza.com
Famed for its pepperoni pizza, Prince Street Pizza serves squares that are a delightful combination of crispy and chewy. The pepperoni curls perfectly under the weight of the melting cheese, creating pools of flavor that are irresistibly savory. Located in Nolita, this spot evokes the vibrant pulse of the neighborhood, making every visit an experience to treasure.
4. Lucali
Address: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 858-4086
Website: lucali.com
A quintessential experience awaits at Lucali, where the rustic ambiance intensifies the delight of traditional pie-making. With its handmade dough and stellar toppings, the margherita pizza is a must-experience. The combination of fresh basil, rich tomatoes, and creamy mozzarella is elevated by the warm, inviting atmosphere of Carroll Gardens. Reservations are highly recommended due to its acclaim among locals.
5. Roberta’s
Address: 261 Moore St, Brooklyn, NY 11206
Contact: (718) 417-7631
Website: robertaspizza.com
Roberta’s is not just a pizzeria; it’s an experience. Located in Bushwick, it reverberates with a youthful, creative energy that extends beyond its wooden beams and ample outdoor seating. The wood-fired pies, especially the “Bee Sting” with its spicy honey drizzle, showcase a bold departure from traditional pizzas, making it an intriguing choice for the adventurous palate.
6. L&B Spumoni Gardens
Address: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223
Contact: (718) 449-1230
Website: spumonigardens.com
Renowned for its Sicilian-style pizza, L&B Spumoni Gardens in Bensonhurst is a family-friendly haven. Here, thick, fluffy crust cradles a rich tomato sauce harmoniously infused with garlic and oregano. Paired with their famed spumoni ice cream, this culinary destination delivers a delightful evening, invoking a sense of nostalgia within its vibrant, lively atmosphere.
7. Patsy’s Pizzeria
Address: 2287 1st Ave, New York, NY 10035
Contact: (212) 289-4811
Website: patsyspizzeria.com
A New York institution since 1933, Patsy’s Pizzeria has been delighting customers with its classic coal oven pizza. The subtle smokiness of each slice, combined with perfectly melted mozzarella and a vibrant sauce, invokes ardent loyalty among its patrons. The East Harlem ambiance resonates with history, serving as a backdrop to every bite.
8. Scarr’s Pizza
Address: 22 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (646) 350-2132
Website: scarrspizza.com
On the Lower East Side, Scarr’s Pizza takes a modern approach with a nod to vintage techniques. This pizzeria prides itself on using a 100-year-old recipe to create the dough, offering a distinctively flavorful bite. Their “homemade” vibe is palpable, and each pizza feels like a lovingly crafted gift to the customer. It is a contemporary homage to traditional pizza-making that draws everyone in.
9. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
Address: 114 1st Ave, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 777-5600
Website: artichokepizza.com
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza captures curiosity with its signature artichoke dip pie. Unique and deliciously creamy, this innovative offering is emblematic of their creativity. The vibrant flavors burst forth, making it a perfect option for those looking to explore beyond the traditional slice. Every bite is an invitation to indulge in experimental enthusiasm.
10. Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitano
Address: 1524 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224
Contact: (718) 372-8600
Website: totonno.com
Nestled in Coney Island, Totonno’s is a storied establishment that serves classic Neapolitan-style pizzas. With its thin, crispy crust and a meticulous attention to ingredient quality, each pie evokes an authentic Italian experience. The vibrant atmosphere and dedicated staff work in concert to create an unforgettable culinary adventure.
Embarking on a pizza pilgrimage through New York’s neighborhoods unveils a world of flavors, textures, and cultural reflections. Each pizzeria on this list promises a tantalizing journey that is as much about the pizza itself as it is about the stories woven into every slice. In a city where culinary creativity knows no bounds, these pizzerias stand out, inviting you to explore the myriad of experiences waiting to be savored in each delicious bite.
