New York City, the veritable mecca of culinary delights, is perhaps best known for its diverse and delectable pizza offerings. With each neighborhood boasting its unique twist on this beloved dish, the quest for the ultimate slice can feel daunting. Are you prepared to embark on a savory adventure that will test your palate against the robust competition of New York’s finest pizzerias? Let’s take a tour of ten quintessentially All-American pizza spots across various neighborhoods, each promising a unique slice of paradise.
As you traverse the energetic boroughs, each destination serves not just pizza, but a story, a history—an experience. Whether you are a New York native or a wide-eyed visitor, these ten pizzerias will tantalize your taste buds and perhaps even ignite an insatiable craving for more!
1. Lombardi’s Pizza
Address: 32 Spring St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 941-7994
Website: www.firstpizza.com
Widely hailed as America’s first pizzeria, Lombardi’s opened in 1905 and remains a staple of New York pizza culture. Its charred, coal-oven crust is the stuff of legends, while its tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella pay homage to traditional Neapolitan styles. The ambiance is electric, filled with camaraderie and the intoxicating aroma of baking dough—ideal for a casual meal with family or friends.
2. Joe’s Pizza
Address: 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 255-3946
Website: www.joespizza.com
For many, the quintessential New York slice can be found at Joe’s Pizza. This iconic establishment, which has been serving delectable cheese slices since 1975, boasts a charming, no-frills setup. Regulars flock here for the slightly crispy crust and the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio. The bustling atmosphere is resonant with the sounds of eager patrons indulging in their favorite late-night snack.
3. Di Fara Pizza
Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230
Contact: (718) 258-1367
Website: www.difarapizza.com
Di Fara isn’t just a pizza joint; it’s an institution. Founded by Domenico DeMarco in 1964, this Brooklyn establishment is revered for its artisanal approach to pizza. Each pie is a labor of love, handcrafted under the watchful eye of DeMarco himself (though recently his family members have taken up the mantle). With premium, imported ingredients and an obsessive attention to detail, a visit to Di Fara is akin to experiencing a piece of culinary history.
4. Prince Street Pizza
Address: 27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 228-0062
Website: www.princestreetpizza.com
Famed for its pepperoni slice, which features perfectly crisped, spicy pepperoni cups, Prince Street Pizza is a sensational stop in Nolita. Each slice is robust and filled with flavors that burst in your mouth, making the wait in often long lines worth every minute. The vibrant atmosphere is as lively as the flavors, attracting locals and tourists alike.
5. Patsy’s Pizzeria
Address: 2287 1st Ave, New York, NY 10035
Contact: (212) 534-9783
Website: www.patsyspizzeria.com
A true embodiment of New York tradition, Patsy’s offers a classic coal-oven pizza experience that has been cherished since 1933. The crust is beautifully crisped with a delightful chewiness, and their margherita is a must-try for any pizza lover. With its timeless feel and consistent quality, Patsy’s has garnered a devoted following that spans generations.
6. Roberta’s
Address: 261 Moore St, Brooklyn, NY 11206
Contact: (718) 417-ROBO
Website: www.robertaspizza.com
A paragon of the artisanal movement, Roberta’s melds creativity with exceptional quality. The restaurant features a wood-fired oven, producing pizzas with a slightly charred crust and imaginative toppings. Whether you opt for the classic Margherita or venture into more eclectic combinations, Roberta’s delivers flavors that dance on the palate, set against a backdrop of hipster Brooklyn.
7. Sylvia’s Pizzeria
Address: 928 E 180th St, Bronx, NY 10460
Contact: (718) 410-5874
Website: www.sylviaspizzeria.com
In the heart of the Bronx, Sylvia’s Pizzeria stands out for its deep-dish offerings and welcoming environment. Born from the spirit of community, this family-operated pizzeria believes in using only the freshest, locally sourced ingredients. Whether it’s a slice of their signature deep-dish or a thin-crust delight, each slice is meant to share love and warmth.
8. Two Boots Pizza
Address: 625 East 9th St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 254-8686
Website: www.twoboots.com
Boldly fusing Italian and New Orleans flavors, Two Boots Pizza is a celebration of cultural culinary amalgamation. Their pies feature creative toppings and quirky names, capturing the essence of both festive atmospheres. From the Cajun-inspired “Bayou Beast” to the classic New York “Cheese,” each creation is a delectable masterpiece, inviting the adventurous foodie to expand their horizons.
9. Motorino
Address: 349 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 777-7770
Website: www.motorinopizza.com
A pioneer of authentic Neapolitan pizza in NYC, Motorino serves irresistible pies that whisk you away to the streets of Naples. The charred crust, carefully curated toppings, and house-made mozzarella create an indulgent experience. The aesthetically pleasing restaurant offers a cozy ambiance that’s perfect for couples looking for a romantic night out or friends catching up over slices.
10. Slice Joint
Address: 1362 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11216
Contact: (718) 393-0499
Website: www.slicejoint.com
The brainchild of two pizza-loving friends, Slice Joint has garnered a loyal fanbase with its innovative flavors and laid-back attitude. Here, you’ll find gourmet toppings and seasonal specialties that elevate the humble slice into a culinary art form. The welcoming neighborhood vibe makes this place an absolute gem for locals and tourists alike.
As you explore these pizzerias, consider the age-old question: What truly makes the perfect pizza? Is it the crust, the sauce, the cheese, or perhaps the love infused into each pie? Each establishment provides its unique perspective and flavor profile that sparks a delicious debate among enthusiasts. Are you ready to take on the challenge of tasting your way through New York City’s pizza landscape? The adventure awaits.
