In the sprawling tapestry of New York City, each neighborhood offers a microcosm of culture, vibrancy, and, of course, culinary delights. Among these delights, the humble pizza stands as a gastronomic stalwart, a shared experience that transcends socio-economic barriers. What if you could savor this iconic dish without emptying your wallet? Today, we journey through ten exceptional establishments where a delicious slice awaits you, all for the beguiling price of just 99 cents. Whether you’re a bustling professional, a college student, or a curious tourist, these venues encapsulate the essence of New York’s pizza culture while remaining remarkably budget-friendly.
1. Joe’s Pizza
Address: 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 255-3940
Website: joespizza.com
Rumored to be a rite of passage for New Yorkers, Joe’s Pizza captures the quintessential essence of a classic slice. As you enter this modest eatery, the aroma of bubbling mozzarella and freshly baked dough envelops you like a warm embrace. The crisp, thin crust, adorned with vibrant tomato sauce and a sprinkle of oregano, delivers an experience reminiscent of a summer day’s picnic.
2. 2 Bros Pizza
Address: 335 East 14th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 529-5366
Website: 2brospizza.com
This establishment is like a beacon for late-night wanderers, offering slices that entice the weary traveler. 2 Bros Pizza has mastered the delicate balance of affordability and flavor. Here, each slice is a masterclass in simplicity; the crust is a golden hug, the cheese has a melodic stretch, and the scattered pepperoni dances with unrestrained excitement.
3. Lenny’s Pizza
Address: 2 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223
Contact: (718) 372-0696
Website: lennyspizza.com
Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Lenny’s Pizza is a culinary institution that boasts a legacy as rich as its toppings. Each slice tells a story of tradition, capturing the nostalgia of neighborhood gatherings. The crust, soft yet crisp, cradles an explosion of flavors—from the robust tomato base to the layers of gooey cheese. At Lenny’s, food transcends nourishment; it becomes a celebration of community.
4. NY Pizza Suprema
Address: 413 W 31st St, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (212) 594-1744
Website: nypizzasuprema.com
In the shadow of Madison Square Garden, NY Pizza Suprema stands as a culinary lighthouse. Its thick slices are like skyscrapers in a city skyline—sturdy, enchanting, and brimming with life. The gooey cheese, coupled with a sweet, tangy sauce, creates a harmonious symphony that resonates with every bite. A slice here is not just a meal; it’s an experience waiting to unfold.
5. Pizza Suprema
Address: 413 W 31st St, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (212) 594-1744
Website: pizzasuprema.com
Often mistaken for its neighbor, Pizza Suprema is a gem that truly deserves attention. The emphasis on using fresh ingredients sets this establishment apart. Each slice is an ode to craftsmanship, with the dough made daily to ensure the perfect mouthfeel. The blend of artisanal cheese and locally sourced vegetables turn each bite into a delightful revelation, offering something extraordinary at an astonishingly low price.
6. Sal & Carmine’s Pizza
Address: 2672 Broadway, New York, NY 10025
Contact: (212) 316-0955
Website: salcarmine.com
At Sal & Carmine’s, quality reigns supreme. This family-run haven encapsulates the rustic charm of old-world Italy. Their slices are generous in size, with golden crusts that lend a satisfying crunch. The unique combinations of toppings offer a culinary journey that evokes memories of sunlit terraces and joyful gatherings, making this spot a beloved fixture among locals.
7. Brooklyn’s Best Pizza
Address: 203 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Contact: (718) 369-1188
Website: brooklynsbestpizza.com
In the heart of Park Slope, Brooklyn’s Best Pizza is a creative bastion of flavors. The vibrant atmosphere mirrors the artistic spirit of its surroundings. Each slice, with its fresh produce and unique toppings, is a culinary canvas where innovation meets tradition. The mélange of textures and tastes ensures that each visit is delightfully different and irresistibly memorable.
8. Amazing Pizza
Address: 1483 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10075
Contact: (212) 737-2222
Website: amazingpizza.com
As its name suggests, Amazing Pizza lives up to the hype by delivering slices that embody both flavor and fun. The crust’s airy texture juxtaposes the savory toppings in a delightful dance. Here, families and groups gather, sharing laughter and stories over their favorite slices, turning mere sustenance into a fortifying adventure.
9. Patzeria Perfect Pizza
Address: 224 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 391-9000
Website: patzeriapizza.com
Tucked away in the vibrant theater district, Patzeria Perfect Pizza is a sanctuary for both tourists and locals alike. The inviting atmosphere complements the irresistible aroma of freshly baked pizza. Each slice is a testament to the art of pizza-making, featuring a perfectly balanced sauce, a symphony of cheeses, and toppings that entice the senses, making it a perfect pitstop before a show.
10. Scarr’s Pizza
Address: 22 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (646) 590-2230
Website: scarrspizza.com
Located on the Lower East Side, Scarr’s Pizza reimagines the classic slice with a nostalgic nod to retro pizzerias. The artisanal approach emphasizes high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, and the result is an explosion of flavor that both honors tradition and embraces innovation. The rustic decor invites you to slow down and relish your experience with every savory bite.
In the kaleidoscope of New York City’s neighborhoods, these ten pizzerias exemplify the allure of affordability without compromising quality. At just 99 cents a slice, they offer not only a meal but a cherished moment shared in the bustling symphony of city life. Each slice becomes a prelude to stories waiting to unfold, nourishing not just the body but also the spirit of camaraderie. So, whether you are a native or a newcomer, let these pizzerias guide you through the mosaic of flavors that define the enchanting culinary landscape of New York.
