Strawberry rhubarb pie is a quintessential dessert that harmoniously combines the sweetness of strawberries with the tartness of rhubarb, creating a delightful symphony of flavors. This pie has garnered a dedicated following across New York City, where passionate bakers have perfected their own mythical interpretations. The gastronomic culture of New York City thrives on diversity, and what better illustration than these ten establishments that showcase this culinary classic? Here is a carefully curated list of ten famed strawberry rhubarb pies scattered throughout various neighborhoods, complemented by essential details such as addresses, contacts, and websites.
1. Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Address: 439 Third Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Contact: (718) 499-2917
Website: birdsblack.com
Located in the heart of Gowanus, Four & Twenty Blackbirds elevates the humble strawberry rhubarb pie to art. Known for its flaky, buttery crust and perfect balance of tart and sweet, this pie embodies the essence of artisanal baking. Each bite transports you to a summer day filled with fresh-picked strawberries, and the faint echo of tart rhubarb brings an extraordinary depth to this classic dish.
2. Petee’s Pie Company
Address: 60 E 16th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (646) 692-4915
Website: peteespie.com
A bustling pie shop nestled in the East Village, Petee’s Pie Company is revered for its unwavering commitment to quality ingredients and traditional recipes. Their strawberry rhubarb pie, featuring fruit sourced from local farms, is unparalleled. The crust is lovingly handmade, ensuring a delightful texture that encapsulates the vibrant flavors, connecting the consumer to the very roots of the farm-to-table movement.
3. The Pie Shop
Address: 970 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205
Contact: (718) 804-8132
Website: thepieshop.com
The Pie Shop stands as an ode to all things delightful. Their strawberry rhubarb pie, characterized by its rich, buttery crust and just the right amount of sugar, is a crowd-pleaser. It’s a testament to the notion that simplicity can yield spectacular results. Each pie is a reminder that delicious food can elicit memories of home-cooked goodness, making it an emotional experience.
4. Baked
Address: 359 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 222-0345
Website: bakednyc.com
In Red Hook, Baked offers a whimsical twist on traditional desserts. Their rendition of strawberry rhubarb pie is imbued with a carefully crafted streusel topping that adds a delightful crunch. The unique flavor combination encapsulates the ethos of creativity and innovation; it’s a representation of how tradition can be reimagined, appealing to both sentimentalists and modern palate seekers alike.
5. Little Pie Company
Address: 420 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 974-0929
Website: littlepiecompany.com
Little Pie Company is a jewel in Hell’s Kitchen, renowned for their homemade pies that celebrate seasonal ingredients. Their strawberry rhubarb pie is a perennial favorite, featuring a perfectly balanced filling that dances between sweet and tart. This establishment’s dedication to preserving traditional methods while incorporating local flavors offers an authentic taste of New York’s dynamic culinary landscape.
6. Blue Sky Bakery
Address: 871 W 166th St, New York, NY 10032
Contact: (646) 864-7764
Website: blueskybakerynyc.com
In the tranquil realm of Washington Heights, Blue Sky Bakery delights locals with its extraordinary strawberry rhubarb pie. The harmonious marriage of flavors makes each slice memorable and flavorful. The bakery’s commitment to social change by employing disadvantaged youth adds a deeper significance to their offerings, creating a sense of community that goes beyond mere gastronomy.
7. Sweet Land
Address: 1765 1st Ave, New York, NY 10128
Contact: (917) 261-9913
Website: sweetlandnyc.com
Located on the Upper East Side, Sweet Land brings a unique touch to the quintessential strawberry rhubarb pie. Their secret is the infusion of lemon zest, which elevates the fruitiness and intrigues the palate. This bakery encapsulates the elegance of the neighborhood within its sophisticated desserts; it is a perfect spot for a tranquil afternoon pie break.
8. Piegirl
Address: 3021 Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11218
Contact: (718) 854-1800
Website: piegirl.com
Piegirl, a whimsical name for a charming bakery, houses artisanal pies with great care and passion. Their strawberry rhubarb pie showcases a deep, complex filling and an exceptional crust, garnered from meticulous attention to detail. The cozy atmosphere invites customers to take a moment to relish the delicious offerings while savoring a cup of robust coffee.
9. The Good Batch
Address: 186 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Contact: (718) 230-1300
Website: thegoodbatch.com
In Prospect Lefferts Gardens, The Good Batch is known for its remarkable pie-making prowess. Their strawberry rhubarb pie utilizes seasonal produce, ensuring freshness that sings in every bite. The bakery’s ethos revolves around quality, craftsmanship, and community, making their pies not just desserts, but vehicles of connection within the neighborhood.
10. Pies N’ Thighs
Address: 166 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 384-1299
Website: piesnthighs.com
Pies N’ Thighs is a beloved establishment in Williamsburg, offering a southern twist to their pies. Their strawberry rhubarb incarnation is no exception, combining traditional flavors with a hint of nostalgia. The infusion of southern charm into the vibrant Brooklyn scene creates a unique fusion, appealing to diverse audiences and inviting them to savor a taste of home.
In the vibrant boroughs of New York City, strawberry rhubarb pie extends beyond being just a dessert; it represents stories of individual bakers, seasonal offerings, and heartfelt connections. Each bakery on this list weaves its narrative through the flavors and traditions cherished by the city’s communities. Exploring the dynamic neighborhoods and indulging in these pies encapsulates not only a sensory experience but also a celebration of culture, creativity, and connection. Dive into the world of strawberry rhubarb pie, and let each bite take you on a journey through the streets and stories of New York.
