Rhubarb pie, with its tangy-sweet filling nestled within flaky crust, is a quintessential dessert that evokes both nostalgia and culinary curiosity. In the vibrant tapestry of New York neighborhoods, finding the perfect rhubarb pie can be an indulgent quest. Does the richness of the pie really vary from one borough to another? That’s the playful challenge we throw out to adventurous eaters: how many different interpretations of rhubarb pie can you discover in this storytelling city? Embark on this delectable journey through ten distinct locales, each with its own take on this classic dessert.
1. Pie Corps
Address: 101 E. 6th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11218
Contact: (347) 763-9634
Website: www.piecorps.com
Located in the heart of Brooklyn, Pie Corps specializes in handcrafted pies, and their rhubarb pie is no exception. With a buttery, perfectly flaky crust that crumbles effortlessly, the filling bursts with the vibrant, tart flavor of fresh rhubarb, paired harmoniously with a hint of vanilla. A stroll in the nearby Prospect Park makes for a perfect end to your pie pilgrimage.
2. Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Address: 439 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Contact: (718) 499-2917
Website: www.birdsblack.com
Four & Twenty Blackbirds is renowned for its artisanal pies, and their rhubarb offering is a celebration of both tradition and innovation. The pie features a meticulous lattice top, allowing the vivid filling to shine through. With its balance of sweetness and tartness, each bite feels like a nostalgic embrace. It’s the perfect companion to an afternoon coffee nearby.
3. Junior’s Restaurant
Address: 386 Flatbush Avenue Extension, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Contact: (718) 852-5257
Website: www.juniorscheesecake.com
While Junior’s is famed for its cheesecake, their rhubarb pie is a hidden jewel worthy of attention. This generous pie is laden with a vibrant filling and a dash of cinnamon, creating a unique taste profile that deviates deliciously from the conventional. The bustling atmosphere offers an invigorating backdrop for a satisfying dessert experience.
4. Sweet Lady Jane
Address: 1051 2nd Avenue, New York, NY 10022
Contact: (212) 377-2700
Website: www.sweetladyjane.com
Nestled in Manhattan, Sweet Lady Jane is a delightful sanctuary for pie enthusiasts. Their rhubarb pie is renowned for its ephemeral crust and harmonious balance of textures and flavors. The inclusion of strawberries with the rhubarb creates a dynamic interplay that invites you to savor every last morsel. Could this be your new go-to spot for celebrations?
5. Pies ‘n’ Thighs
Address: 166 S 4th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 599-2148
Website: www.piesnthighs.com
Pies ‘n’ Thighs is not just about comfort food; it’s a celebration of Southern cuisine with a quirky twist. Their rhubarb pie stands out with its unique spice infusion that tantalizes the palate. When paired with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, the experience becomes an unforgettable southern delight. Dare to challenge your taste buds with this delightful savory surprise?
6. Bubby’s
Address: 120 Hudson Street, New York, NY 10013
Contact: (212) 219-0666
Website: www.bubbys.com
Bubby’s brings a sense of homeliness with its hearty meals and comforting desserts. Their rhubarb pie showcases a country-style charm—rustic in presentation but delectable in flavor. The sweet crust, combined with a hint of tartness from the rhubarb, evokes reminiscences of grandmother’s kitchen. Could this be the pinnacle of nostalgia for dessert lovers?
7. The Little Pie Company
Address: 420 W 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 736-4780
Website: www.littlepiecompany.com
Famed for artisan pies, The Little Pie Company’s rhubarb pie is a splendid homage to simplicity. Crafted with care, the pie offers a refreshing burst of rhubarb flavor, balanced with a sugar glaze that enhances its natural sweetness. A perfect stop for theater goers looking for a whimsical touch to their night out!
8. Magnolia Bakery
Address: 401 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 462-2572
Website: www.magnoliabakery.com
Known for its cupcakes, Magnolia Bakery surprises with its equally noteworthy rhubarb pie. This version is an ode to classic American desserts, with generous chunks of rhubarb nestled within a rich custard-like filling. Their vintage ambiance adds to the allure, making it more than a dessert stop—it’s an experience. Will you be drawn to the allure of its charming atmosphere?
9. The Greenwich Village Pie Shop
Address: 121 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 777-3636
Website: www.greenwichvillagepies.com
At the Greenwich Village Pie Shop, rhubarb pie embodies the spirit of seasonal cuisine. With a local twist, this pie features organically sourced rhubarb that showcases the freshness of farm-to-table dining. Coupled with a warm, convivial atmosphere, enjoying this pie becomes a communal affair. Will you dive into this pie sharing experience?
10. A Piece of Cake
Address: 153 W 71st Street, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 580-1900
Website: www.apieceofcake.com
This quaint bakery is a gem for pie lovers exploring the Upper West Side. Their rhubarb pie encapsulates the essence of spring with a light, refreshing filling that avoids overwhelming sweetness. The flaky crust offers a satisfying crunch, inviting patrons to appreciate the craftsmanship. Will this become your favorite hidden gem in the city?
In traversing these vibrant neighborhoods of New York, indulging in rhubarb pie becomes more than just sampling a dessert; it’s a playful exploration of flavors, traditions, and bakery craftsmanship. Will you accept the challenge to taste each unique rhubarb pie and discover your favorite? Each bite tells a story, and embarking on this gastronomic adventure promises delightful surprises along the way.
