Pickled eggs may seem like a humble snack, but in the bustling and eclectic food scene of New York City, they are a culinary delight waiting to be discovered. This list of ten establishments across various neighborhoods offers a journey through flavors and textures—each pickled egg brings with it a unique story and a distinct character that reflects its surroundings. Whether you are a connoisseur of pickled delicacies or a curious foodie, these gems promise to elevate your palate and pique your curiosity.
1. The Pickled Egg
Address: 1730 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031
Contact: (212) 222-1234
Website: thepickledeggnyc.com
Nestled in the heart of Harlem, The Pickled Egg offers a myriad of artisan pickled eggs, each steeped in a variety of spices and ingredients. This establishment prides itself on locally sourced materials, with flavors ranging from classic dill to craft variations like beet-pickled eggs. Pair them with a craft beer for an unexpectedly delightful combination.
2. McSorley’s Old Ale House
Address: 15 E 7th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 473-9148
Website: mcsorleysoldalehouse.com
As a historic establishment dating back to 1854, McSorley’s Old Ale House serves pickled eggs steeped in tradition. The ambience of the pub is steeped in nostalgia, and the eggs stand out as an icon on the menu. Paired with a pint of their house ale, these pickled wonders are a quintessential experience for anyone seeking to embrace the past while savoring the present.
3. Ghetto Gastro
Address: 1620 Sedgwick Ave, Bronx, NY 10453
Contact: (718) 801-6880
Website: ghettogastro.com
Ghetto Gastro challenges culinary norms with bold flavors and innovative dishes. Their pickled eggs incorporate unique ingredients like jalapeño and mango, balancing heat and sweetness in each bite. This Bronx-based establishment focuses on community engagement, inviting patrons to experience food as a catalyst for cultural dialogue.
4. The Brooklyn Diner
Address: 100 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 246-0500
Website: brooklyndiner.com
A love letter to Americana, The Brooklyn Diner offers traditional pickled eggs that are perfect for nostalgic diners. Emphasizing the old-school charm, the eggs are served as a classic appetizer, evoking memories of family gatherings and fairs. The diner’s ambiance is inviting, making it a perfect spot for a leisurely meal.
5. Tasty Diner
Address: 32 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10010
Contact: (212) 691-0200
Website: tastydiner.com
At Tasty Diner, taste and nostalgia converge. Their pickled eggs showcase a delightful array of flavors that resonate with the New York spirit. The charming, diner-style setting adds to the experience, allowing guests to unwind while savoring their tangy, bold, and consistently delicious pickled eggs.
6. Johny’s Deli
Address: 851 N 5th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 387-3184
Website: johnysdeli.com
In the vibrant area of Williamsburg, Johny’s Deli crafts a unique pickled egg that mixes cultural influences. Their signature dish combines Eastern European spices, presenting a complex yet harmonious flavor profile that both locals and newcomers appreciate. Dive into this deli to taste the essence of Brooklyn in a bite-sized delight.
7. M. Wells Dinette
Address: 21-25 44th Dr, Queens, NY 11101
Contact: (718) 937-4094
Website: mwellsdinette.com
Housed in a gallery space, M. Wells Dinette offers a refined approach to pickled eggs. Their creations are inspired by the changing seasons, utilizing farm-fresh ingredients to create artisanal masterpieces. This is a destination for the adventurous eater seeking exquisite flavor combinations in a chic atmosphere.
8. The Wayfarer
Address: 201 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 957-1717
Website: thewayfarernyc.com
An upscale spot located in the Theater District, The Wayfarer elevates the humble pickled egg to luxurious status. Here, you can expect gourmet twists and variations, adorned with delectable toppings that transform this classic bar snack into a stand-alone culinary experience, subverting expectations and tantalizing the senses.
9. The Lower East Side Tenement Museum Store
Address: 103 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 431-0233
Website: tenement.org/store
While conceptualized as a museum store, their offering of pickled eggs is a nod to the immigrant experience in New York. These eggs are crafted using age-old recipes with a cultural significance, providing patrons with a taste of history that is as engaging as it is delectable.
10. Schaller’s Stube
Address: 1654 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10128
Contact: (212) 996-1870
Website: schallerstube.com
This German-inspired eatery offers traditional pickled eggs with robust flavors that encapsulate the essence of both classic and modern German cuisine. The inviting decor and hearty menu beckon diners to explore and indulge, making every visit memorable.
Each of these establishments not only serves pickled eggs but also weaves a narrative that enriches the New York dining experience. From dives steeped in history to modern culinary havens, these ten hotspots invite you to delve deep into the diverse tapestry of flavors. Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or someone curious to embark on this unique gastronomic journey, the humble pickled egg awaits your discovery at these remarkable locations.
