When it comes to iconic desserts, Boston Cream Pie reigns supreme, boasting a sumptuous amalgamation of rich chocolate and velvety cream encased within layers of moist cake. Despite its name, this delectable delight can be found gracing the menus of countless establishments far beyond Massachusetts, particularly in the vibrant neighborhoods of New York City. The following list chronicles ten of the best places to indulge in this cherished confectionary wonder, providing not just addresses but also a glimpse into the unique charms of each locale.
1. Baked by Melissa
Address: 1442 Broadway, New York, NY 10018
Contact: (212) 302-0004
Website: bakedbymelissa.com
Known for its diminutive cupcakes, Baked by Melissa puts a cheeky twist on the classic Boston Cream Pie by offering a cupcake version that encapsulates all the flavors in a single bite. The playful ambiance of the shop, combined with its inventive dessert presentations, makes it a must-visit for both locals and tourists alike. The fusion of whimsy and flavor deftly captures the city’s eclectic spirit.
2. Magnolia Bakery
Address: 401 Bleeker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 462-2572
Website: magnoliabakery.com
A stalwart of the West Village, Magnolia Bakery is renowned for its nostalgic treats. The Boston Cream Pie here is no exception; its creamy filling and glossy chocolate glaze hearken back to a simpler time. Surrounded by charming exteriors and bustling streets, the bakery serves as a perfect spot to soak in the enchanting atmosphere while indulging in a slice of history.
3. Flour Bakery + Café
Address: 1143 B Way, New York, NY 10010
Contact: (646) 682-7160
Website: flourbakery.com
Though its original roots are in Boston, Flour Bakery + Café has successfully brought its acclaimed Boston Cream Pie to New Yorkers craving an authentic experience. The slice exemplifies craftsmanship with its layers of soft cake, luscious custard, and glossy chocolate glaze. The inviting café atmosphere beckons patrons to savor the pie while partaking in the social tapestry of the Flatiron District.
4. Eileen’s Special Cheesecake
Address: 17 Cleveland Pl, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 966-5585
Website: eilenescheesecake.com
While primarily a cheesecake haven, Eileen’s Special Cheesecake surprises its visitors with its take on Boston Cream Pie. The infusion of ingredients results in an uncanny balance that delights both cheesecake lovers and die-hard Boston Cream aficionados. Nestled in SoHo, the establishment offers a vibrant, artistic backdrop ideal for dessert lovers seeking a slice of indulgence.
5. Little Pie Company
Address: 420 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 974-0936
Website: littlepiecompany.com
A gem tucked away in Hell’s Kitchen, the Little Pie Company serves up a Boston Cream Pie that captures the heart and soul of traditional baking. The pie’s sumptuous layers convey an artisanal touch, as the bakery is dedicated to using high-quality, seasonal ingredients. The welcoming environment and proximity to Broadway make it a delightful stop for theater-goers.
6. French Patisserie
Address: 507 E 6th St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 673-2226
Website: frenchpatisserie.com
For those enchanted by the meticulous artistry of French desserts, French Patisserie reinterprets the classic Boston Cream Pie with a sophisticated flair. This charming establishment in the East Village produces a pie featuring an excellent blend of French pastry techniques and traditional flavors. Each bite resonates with the history of culinary craftsmanship, embodying the idea that both cultures can coexist harmoniously.
7. The Cake Boutique
Address: 76-11 37th Ave, Jackson Heights, NY 11372
Contact: (718) 458-5668
Website: thecakeboutiqueny.com
A treasure in Jackson Heights, The Cake Boutique specializes in custom cakes and irresistible desserts, with its Boston Cream Pie being an undisputed highlight. This establishment prides itself on community engagement and creating memorable experiences. Here, visitors can enjoy this luscious dessert locally made, surrounded by the rich diversity of Queens.
8. Billie’s Bakery
Address: 310 E 19th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 529-7600
Website: billiesbakeryny.com
Billie’s Bakery offers an exquisite rendition of Boston Cream Pie that reflects the cozy charm of the Upper East Side. The traditional approach to baking comes through in the layered cake, cream filling, and the attention to detail throughout the presentation. It’s the kind of place where neighborhood warmth and gourmet technique meet, creating a welcoming ambiance.
9. Pies ‘n’ Thighs
Address: 166 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 384-PIES
Website: piesnthighs.com
Situated in Williamsburg, Pies ‘n’ Thighs redefines comfort food with its trendy take on classic desserts. The Boston Cream Pie here boasts a playful depth of flavor that invites patrons to experience the intersection of Southern and New England influences. Enjoy this culinary curiosity within a vibrant neighborhood, rich with creativity and innovation.
10. Sweet Lady Jane
Address: 489 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 873-4646
Website: sweetladyjane.com
Sweet Lady Jane brings a West Coast flair to the Big Apple with its delightful version of Boston Cream Pie. The layering is impeccable, bringing a slight twist to the traditional recipe while still paying homage to its roots. The serene atmosphere combined with indulgent treats creates a perfect spot to unwind after a long day.
From the bustling energy of Manhattan to the artistic depths of Brooklyn, each of these establishments offers not just a slice of Boston Cream Pie, but also a taste of New York’s diverse culinary landscape. Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or a curious newcomer, these enticing locales promise to satisfy your sweet tooth while providing an enriching experience woven into the very fabric of the city’s neighborhoods. Explore, savor, and enjoy the journey through this delectable dessert landscape!
