Breaking

10 Bait Worms in New York Neighborhoods

Joaquimma Anna

25 September 2025

New York, a bustling metropolis renowned for its myriad attractions and vibrant culture, is also home to an array of natural wonders that may often go unnoticed. Among these charming treasures are the bait worm vendors scattered throughout its neighborhoods. These intriguing small businesses not only supply essential fishing equipment, but they also foster community connections, create local jobs, and contribute to the lore of urban fishing. As we explore various bait worm vendors across the city, we will delve deeper into the specifics of each establishment, examining their unique characteristics, as well as how they fit into the broader tapestry of New York’s community life. Here’s a curated list of ten notable bait worm vendors in New York City, complete with addresses, contact information, and websites.

1. The Bait Shop
Address: 254 East 135th Street, Bronx, NY 10451
Contact: (718) 901-2500
Website: www.thebaitshop.com

Located in the Bronx, The Bait Shop showcases an impressive array of live bait, including nightcrawlers and red wigglers. Their friendly staff is always eager to assist both novice and experienced anglers. With a strong focus on community engagement, The Bait Shop is known to host fishing clinics and local fishing tournaments, fostering the spirit of camaraderie among neighborhood residents. Their commitment to sustainability also sets them apart, as they source their bait from environmentally responsible suppliers.

2. Brooklyn Worm Company
Address: 89 Halsey Street, Brooklyn, NY 11216
Contact: (718) 555-0123
Website: www.brooklynwormco.com

The Brooklyn Worm Company stands out for its production of high-quality worm composting kits, aimed at eco-conscious consumers. While they cater to various gardening needs, their selection of live bait remains exemplary. This innovative establishment educates its customers about the ecological benefits of composting, bridging the gap between fishing and sustainable gardening practices. The atmosphere is one of conviviality, with workshops on composting and fishing regularly scheduled throughout the year.

3. Yankee Bait and Tackle
Address: 302 Garrison Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10304
Contact: (718) 702-5434
Website: www.yankeebait.com

Situated on Staten Island, Yankee Bait and Tackle is a beloved local institution. They offer an extensive selection of live bait, ranging from worms to minnows, and have an in-house fishing outfitter that can assist with custom rigging. Enthusiastic about the local fishing community, they often have expert anglers drop by for guest lectures and hands-on demos. This intimate connection with the customer base creates an atmosphere that can only be found in family-owned establishments.

4. Montauk Bait & Tackle
Address: 18 S. Elias Road, Montauk, NY 11954
Contact: (631) 668-3730
Website: www.montaukbaitandtackle.com

In the picturesque hamlet of Montauk, this bait and tackle shop is synonymous with summer fishing. Renowned for its superior quality live bait, including bloodworms specifically prized by striped bass anglers, Montauk Bait & Tackle has become a seasonal hotspot for local fishermen and tourists alike. The community atmosphere is palpable; regulars gather to share tales and tips, underlining the strong friendship forged through shared pursuits.

5. Bronx River Bait & Tackle
Address: 1750 Westchester Avenue, Bronx, NY 10462
Contact: (347) 554-0280
Website: www.bronxriverbait.com

Specializing in urban fishing, Bronx River Bait & Tackle appeals to a diverse clientele. They maintain an impressive stock of worms suited for local fishing holes, like the Bronx River itself. Their knowledgeable staff regularly organizes local fishing excursions, promoting environmental awareness through educational discussions about the challenges facing New York’s waterways. This commitment to community outreach underlines their integral role within the neighborhood.

6. Big Apple Bait
Address: 1 Cherry Street, Manhattan, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 555-0199
Website: www.bigapplebait.com

As the name suggests, Big Apple Bait caters primarily to the island’s urban anglers. Set against the backdrop of a vibrant Manhattan neighborhood, this shop specializes in live bait, including various worm species. The store priorities pre-packaged fishing kits tailored for the novice angler. Regular fishing workshops that emphasize the unique aspects of fishing in urban locales offer a unique educational angle to the shopping experience.

7. Queens Fishing Emporium
Address: 2452 Hempstead Turnpike, East Meadow, NY 11554
Contact: (516) 555-0282
Website: www.queensfishingemporium.com

This eclectic emporium in Queens is renowned for its merged assortment of fishing supplies, including worms that you may not find anywhere else in the city. Queens Fishing Emporium is a haven for enthusiasts looking to experiment with various bait types. With their knowledgeable staff frequently stepping out to local fishing spots, they foster an invaluable connection between customer and service provider, enhancing the customer experience.

8. Coney Island Bait Company
Address: 1501 Surf Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11224
Contact: (718) 373-1950
Website: www.coneyislandbait.com

Coney Island Bait Company serves the dual purpose of a bait shop and a cultural landmark, being situated near the iconic amusement parks. Offering an extensive array of fishing supplies, their collection of live bait is remarkable. This location regularly attracts both locals and tourists, providing fishing gear and invaluable tips on the best fishing practices in nearby waters. The ambient seaside environment enhances both the experience and the opportunity for shared stories among fishermen.

9. Staten Island Worm Farm
Address: 945 Richmond Road, Staten Island, NY 10312
Contact: (718) 605-7223
Website: www.statenislandwormfarm.com

The Staten Island Worm Farm stands as an emblem of sustainable fishing, offering a diverse range of worms cultivated onsite. They prioritize organic practices and teach customers about vermiculture as an environmentally friendly bait option. The farm also regularly partners with local schools to educate youth on biodiversity and conservation, making them a cherished resource within the community.

10. Hudson Valley Worms
Address: 345 Main Street, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601
Contact: (845) 555-0129
Website: www.hudsonvalleyworms.com

Located a short distance from New York City, Hudson Valley Worms epitomizes the connection between quality bait and responsible fishing practices. This family-run business offers an engaging selection of worms that not only cater to local anglers but also prioritize education about sustainable fishing. The beautiful Hudson Valley setting adds a layer of tranquility, making it an ideal stop for outdoor enthusiasts.

In conclusion, the alluring world of bait worm vendors in New York City is rich with stories of community, sustainability, and the joys of fishing. Each shop mentioned above not only supplies essential bait but also fosters a sense of belonging among anglers. The persistence of these establishments is a testament to the enduring relationship between urbanity and nature, celebrating the essence of fishing in a city that prides itself on diversity and connection. Whether you are a seasoned angler or a curious novice, these bait worm vendors are well worth a visit, offering more than just worms, but rather an opportunity to engage in the communal pastime of fishing amidst the vibrant tapestry of New York City.

Leave a Comment