If you’re a fan of sweet, tangy, and utterly delightful cherry pie, New York City is home to some of the most exquisite options that passionate bakers have to offer. With each neighborhood showcasing its own unique flair, there exists a veritable treasure trove of cherry pie experiences awaiting discovery. This listicle will guide you through ten noteworthy establishments across various neighborhoods, complete with their addresses, contact details, and websites if available. Prepare yourself for a tour de force of delectable cherry pie options—each slice telling its own story.
1. Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Address: 439 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Contact: (718) 499-2917
Website: fourandtwentyblackbirds.com
Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Four & Twenty Blackbirds is a pioneer in the artisanal pie movement. Their cherry pie, made from hand-picked local cherries, comes with a buttery, flaky crust that is undeniably mouthwatering. Expect a classic blend of sweet and tart flavors, harmonized beautifully by a hint of vanilla. The charm of this spot lies not just in the pie but also in the warm, inviting atmosphere.
2. The Pie Hole
Address: 560 Mott Street, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (646) 850-4000
Website: thepiehole.com
The Pie Hole, with its quaint decor and cozy ambience, serves a cherry pie that has gained a cult following. Baked fresh daily, their signature pie features a delightful lattice crust that hints at nostalgia. The filling is made from a well-guarded family recipe that strikes the perfect balance between sweet cherries and rich spices. Each bite transports you to simpler times, resonating with sentimental flavor.
3. Baked
Address: 359 Van Brunt Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 222-0345
Website: bakednyc.com
For those who adore a great pie with a modern twist, Baked offers a cherry pie that is both decadent and innovative. Known for their creative ingredients, the bakers at Baked incorporate seasonal fruits into their fillings. Their cherry pie is a delightful medley, bursting with juicy cherries, aromatic ginger, and infused with a hint of orange zest. This vibrant concoction is as visually appealing as it is delicious.
4. Sarabeth’s Bakery
Address: 40 Central Park South, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 826-5959
Website: sarabeths.com
Sarabeth’s Bakery has made a name for itself as a purveyor of luxury baked goods. Their cherry pie is simply sublime, encapsulating all the classic elements of a timeless dessert. With its rich, deep-red filling, the pie boasts a perfect balance of tartness and sweetness, complemented by its crisp, golden-brown crust. Don’t forget to accompany it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, enhancing your cherry-filled experience further.
5. The Little Pie Company
Address: 424 West 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 736-4780
Website: littlepiecompany.com
This hidden gem prides itself on handcrafting every pie with utmost dedication. The cherry pie at The Little Pie Company is no exception; it is made using only the finest organic cherries, and the crust is made from scratch daily. This establishment prides itself on using sustainable farming practices, making the pie not only delicious but also environmentally friendly. Each slice is a triumph of flavor and conscience.
6. Magnolia Bakery
Address: 401 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 462-2572
Website: magnoliabakery.com
Magnolia Bakery is synonymous with nostalgia, epitomizing classic American desserts. Their cherry pie is a celebration of simplicity, showcasing a beautifully baked crust enveloping a luscious cherry filling. The delightful sprinkle of sugar on top adds a light crunch, which complements the soft filling perfectly. Popular for dessert lovers of all ages, this bakery offers a quintessential cherry pie experience.
7. Little Cupcake Bakeshop
Address: 30 Prince Street, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 677-7888
Website: littlecupcakebakeshop.com
A whimsical bakeshop tucked away in Nolita, Little Cupcake specializes in delightful confections, including an unforgettable cherry pie. Their rendition features a crumbly crust that delivers a satisfying crunch, while the cherry filling shines bright with its luscious texture. Not merely a dessert, it’s an experience here. The atmosphere exudes charm, making it an ideal location for pie enthusiasts.
8. Pie by the Pound
Address: 292 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 924-9500
Website: piebythepound.com
Pie by the Pound is a beloved spot that captures the essence of homemade goodness. Their cherry pie is awash in flavor, marrying sweet, tart cherries with a perfectly executed crust. Generous portions are the hallmark here; you won’t leave without a satisfying slice. The cozy, laid-back atmosphere invites patrons to linger longer as they savor their culinary choice.
9. Petee’s Pie Company
Address: 60 Greene Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Contact: (718) 522-1222
Website: peteespie.com
Petee’s Pie Company elevates pie-making to an art form. Their cherry pie is crafted using a unique blend of tart and sweet cherries, enveloped in a handmade crust. The pie features a visually stunning lattice top, promising not just taste but an arresting presentation as well. Locals rave about this pie’s rich, complex flavor that unfolds with each delectable bite, further enhancing the overall sensory experience.
10. Pies ‘n’ Thighs
Address: 166 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 384-1954
Website: piesnthighs.com
Renowned for its Southern-inspired fare, Pies ‘n’ Thighs offers an exquisite cherry pie that tantalizes the taste buds with its homemade crust and luscious filling. The balance of sweet and tart flavors captures the essence of cherry, conjuring memories of summer. The casual, friendly environment makes it a perfect eatery for family and friends to gather over a slice—or two.
In conclusion, whether you cherish the nostalgia of a classic slice or are intrigued by modern variations, New York harbors a diverse collection of cherry pies that cater to every palate. These ten establishments are testaments to the city’s rich culinary tapestry, each boasting its own unique interpretation of this timeless dessert. As you embark on your cherry pie exploration, keep in mind the distinctive flavors and distinct settings that make each of these local pie shops worthwhile destinations. Grab a fork and dive into these scrumptious offerings—you won’t be disappointed!
