New York City is a melting pot of cultures and flavors, and at the heart of this vibrant culinary scene lies the key lime. While Florida is often associated with this tangy fruit, key limes have found a fascinating niche across various neighborhoods in New York. Have you ever wondered where to find the most delectable key lime-infused treats in the Big Apple? This quest may seem playful, but identifying the best spots presents an exciting challenge for dessert enthusiasts and adventurous palates alike. Here’s a list of ten key locations known for their delightful key lime offerings, complete with addresses, contact information, and websites for your convenience.
1. **Clementine Bakery**
Address: 490 Lorimer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 384-2127
Website: clementinebakeries.com
Clementine Bakery is a plant-based establishment that serves an array of satisfying desserts, including an exquisite key lime pie that is both creamy and tart. The bakery places a strong emphasis on using organic ingredients, making each bite guilt-free and delicious.
2. **Magnolia Bakery**
Address: 401 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 462-2572
Website: magnoliabakery.com
Famous for its classic American baked goods, Magnolia Bakery serves a key lime pie that embodies the essence of summer. With a buttery crust and a zesty filling, it’s a must-try for anyone visiting the West Village.
3. **The Key Lime Pie Company**
Address: 332 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 924-7463
Website: keylimepie.com
This charming shop specializes solely in key lime pie and showcases variations that will delight your taste buds. From traditional to innovative versions, The Key Lime Pie Company is dedicated to providing the ultimate key lime experience.
4. **Dough**
Address: 448 Lafayette Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205
Contact: (718) 622-2999
Website: doughdoughnuts.com
Dough is known for its artisanal donuts, and although key lime is not the star on their menu, the key lime coconut donut will make you reconsider. This delightful treat merges the flavors of key lime and coconut, resulting in an indulgent fusion that is hard to resist.
5. **Brooklyn Cake Shop**
Address: 39 Horace Ct, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Contact: (347) 963-6968
Website: brooklyncakeshop.com
At Brooklyn Cake Shop, the key lime pie is a deliciously traditional dessert that boasts a unique twist with local ingredients. The perfect balance of sweetness and acidity elevates it beyond conventional offerings, making it a true standout in the neighborhood.
6. **Friedman’s**
Address: 25 W 29th St, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (212) 727-1600
Website: friedmansrestaurant.com
Friedman’s is a beloved spot that prides itself on comfort food. Their key lime pie is reimagined as a tart, topping any meal on the menu with a flavorful finish. Its light and refreshing taste makes it an ideal dessert choice for any occasion.
7. **Pineapple Co.**
Address: 63 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 268-7630
Website: pineappleco.com
Pineapple Co. is a vibrant eatery that offers a key lime pie parfait, perfect for those who crave a twist on the classic. Served in a cup with layers of graham cracker crumbles and key lime filling, this dish exudes freshness with every spoonful.
8. **Ample Hills Creamery**
Address: 623 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Contact: (917) 602-0013
Website: amplehills.com
Known for its creative ice cream flavors, Ample Hills Creamery elevates the key lime experience by offering a key lime pie ice cream flavor. This frozen treat encapsulates the essence of the pie while providing a refreshing way to enjoy it during warmer months.
9. **The Little Pie Company**
Address: 420 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 736-4780
Website: littlepiecompany.com
The Little Pie Company specializes in handmade pies, with their key lime pie being a noteworthy staple. Renowned for its perfectly balanced flavor profile, it is crafted from fresh key limes and provides a zesty kick that keeps customers returning.
10. **Gordon Ramsay Burger**
Address: 170 W 51st St, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 246-2545
Website: gordonramsayrestaurants.com
While this may primarily be known for its burgers, Gordon Ramsay Burger surprises diners with an exceptional key lime pie dessert. This contemporary twist combines elements of modern gastronomy, appealing to those looking for a gourmet take on a classic dish.
As you traverse the diverse neighborhoods of New York City, keep this list in mind. Whether you’re in search of a traditional slice or an inventive new creation, the key lime pie scene is thriving. Will you rise to the challenge of sampling each unique variation and discovering your personal favorite? Happy tasting!
