Butter, a quintessential ingredient in the culinary repertoire, can elevate a dish from mundane to magnificent. Have you ever pondered where to find the most exquisite butters in New York? With a plethora of artisanal shops and gourmet grocery stores scattered throughout the city, the hunt for the perfect butter could be seen as a delightful challenge. Below is a curated list of ten exceptional butters available in different neighborhoods of New York, each with distinct characteristics and flavors that may pique your interest.
1. Murray’s Cheese
Address: 254 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 243-3289
Website: www.murrayscheese.com
Murray’s Cheese is renowned for its expansive selection of artisanal cheeses, but their rich, creamy butter deserves equal attention. Sourced from local farms, their signature butter is churned in small batches and imparts an exceptional flavor profile perfect for slathering on freshly baked bread.
2. The Butter Shop
Address: 113 E 72nd St, New York, NY 10021
Contact: (212) 772-5255
Website: www.thebuttershop.com
An establishment dedicated entirely to butter, The Butter Shop offers a myriad of flavored butters that can tantalize your palate. From smoked sea salt to herb-infused varieties, there’s something here for everyone. Be prepared to indulge in their signature butter tasting flights!
3. Dean & DeLuca
Address: 560 Broadway, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 226-6800
Website: www.deandeluca.com
This upscale gourmet grocery store stocks a selection of high-quality butters from across the world. Their French butter, which contains a higher fat content than typical American varieties, makes it an indulgent choice for pastry-making or simply enjoying on its own.
4. Whole Foods Market
Address: 10 Columbus Circle, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 823-9600
Website: www.wholefoodsmarket.com
Known for its commitment to organic and sustainable products, Whole Foods offers a variety of butters, including grass-fed options that are nutritionally superior. Their exclusive in-house brand also features seasonal flavored butters that are worth exploring.
5. Saxelby Cheesemongers
Address: 80 Greenwich St, New York, NY 10006
Contact: (212) 274-9450
Website: www.saxelbycheese.com
Situated in the historic Chelsea Market, Saxelby Cheesemongers features a fantastic range of local butters. Highlighting small-batch producers, their selection often includes unique flavors influenced by the region’s farming practices.
6. Fairway Market
Address: 2328 Broadway, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 874-3115
Website: www.fairwaymarket.com
With its charming atmosphere and unparalleled selection, Fairway Market is a go-to destination for food enthusiasts. Here, you can find artisanal butters sourced from New York farms, featuring local flavors that epitomize the region’s culinary identity.
7. Zabar’s
Address: 2245 Broadway, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 787-2000
Website: www.zabars.com
A beloved institution on the Upper West Side, Zabar’s combines a traditional deli experience with gourmet offerings. Their own line of butters includes mouthwatering variations such as truffle and garlic, giving any dish a gourmet twist.
8. Greenmarket
Location: Various locations throughout New York City
Contact: (212) 788-7900
Website: www.grownyc.org/greenmarket
Visiting a Greenmarket not only supports local farmers but also provides an opportunity to purchase homemade butters. Frequently featuring vendors who specialize in small-batch products, the Greenmarket is a great place to find unique flavors and artisanal craftsmanship.
9. Eataly
Address: 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
Contact: (212) 229-2560
Website: www.eataly.com
Eataly blends a marketplace and a culinary experience, showcasing products from Italy and beyond. Their array of imported butters, particularly those from French and Italian makers, adds a touch of authenticity to any dish you may create at home.
10. Butter & Scotch
Address: 818 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Contact: (718) 484-2626
Website: www.butterandscotch.com
Renowned for its innovative desserts, Butter & Scotch uses high-quality butter in its recipes. While you can indulge in their sweet creations, you can also purchase their signature vanilla-infused butter to recreate the magic at home.
Choosing the right butter is akin to selecting a fine wine; the nuances and quality can significantly impact your culinary creations. Each of these establishments not only offers butter but also an experience, giving you a glimpse into New York’s dynamic food culture. Challenge yourself to visit several on this list and discover which butter becomes your personal favorite.
