Tomatillos, often overshadowed by their more widely known counterparts like tomatoes and peppers, are a staple in Mexican cuisine. Their tart flavor and unique texture make them ideal for salsas, sauces, and even desserts. In New York City, a melting pot of diverse cultures and flavors, several eateries specialize in this underappreciated ingredient. Below, we explore ten establishments where tomatillos are not merely an afterthought but the star of the culinary show.
1. La Botanera
Address: 211 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 486-3535
Website: labotanera.com
As a vibrant spot in Williamsburg, La Botanera serves up innovative Mexican dishes. Their tomatillo salsa is a crowd favorite, striking a balance between tangy and spicy. The ambiance is casual, with artfully crafted decor that reflects the richness of Mexican culture.
2. La Esquina
Address: 106 Kenmare St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 219-1969
Website: esquinanyc.com
Situated in NoLiTa, La Esquina offers a unique dining experience with a hidden taqueria. The house-made tomatillo salsa pairs perfectly with tacos al pastor, drawing in locals and tourists alike. The ambiance blends rustic charm with modern influences, making it a go-to for authentic Mexican fare.
3. Cafe Mexicano
Address: 464 W 149th St, New York, NY 10031
Contact: (646) 488-7995
Website: cafemexicano.com
Located in Harlem, this charming café pays homage to traditional Mexican flavors. Their tomatillo-based dishes are crafted with fresh ingredients sourced from local markets, making every meal a unique experience. The welcoming atmosphere and delicious food make it a staple in the community.
4. Taqueria Diana
Address: 951 Queen St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 858-8513
Website: taqueriadiana.com
Known for its sustainability practices, Taqueria Diana is committed to using organic ingredients. Their tomatillo salsa verde is a standout, offering a refreshing contrast to rich, savory dishes. The sleek design and eco-friendly ethos create a remarkable dining experience.
5. Tortilleria Nixtamal
Address: 104-05 Gladstone Ave, Corona, NY 11368
Contact: (718) 699-1861
Website: tortillerianixtamal.com
This venue is a haven for all traditional Mexican food enthusiasts. Famous for making fresh tortillas, Tortilleria Nixtamal serves tomatillo salsa that complements their corn-based creations flawlessly. The straightforward decor focuses on the culinary process, allowing patrons to appreciate the craft behind the cuisine.
6. Los Tacos No. 1
Address: 229 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (646) 349-2020
Website: lostacos1.com
With its humble beginnings as a food stall, Los Tacos No. 1 has grown into a beloved entity in NYC. Their tomatillo salsa, vibrant and fresh, enhances tacos, quesadillas, and beyond. The bustling atmosphere makes it a delightful stop for taco lovers on the go.
7. Dos Toros
Address: 4 locations in NYC, including 132 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (646) 350-0056
Website: dostoros.com
Blending a fast-casual concept with high-quality ingredients, Dos Toros serves up a fantastic tomatillo salsa that’s both zesty and aromatic. The chain boasts multiple locations, making it accessible for those seeking a quick but satisfying meal without sacrificing flavor.
8. Mercado Little Spain
Address: 10 Hudson Yards, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (212) 730-2555
Website: mercadolittlespain.com
This culinary emporium features a vibrant homage to Spanish and Latin foods. Among its authentic offerings, the tomatillos shine in various dishes, from refreshing sauces to hearty entrees. The ambience perfectly combines a market and dining space, appealing to both foodies and casual diners.
9. Fonda
Address: 40 Fonda St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 253-2233
Website: fondanyc.com
Dubbed a quintessential neighborhood spot in the Lower East Side, Fonda emphasizes traditional and contemporary Mexican cuisine. Their tomatillo sauce is versatile, found on various menu items, showcasing the ingredient’s adaptability. The warmth of the staff complements the inviting atmosphere.
10. Xochitl
Address: 45 Bedford St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 255-2923
Website: xochitlnyc.com
In the heart of the West Village, Xochitl merges authentic flavors with modern flair. Their tomatillo-based sauces offer a delightful zing that harmonizes with various dishes. The elegant décor and sophisticated presentation elevate the dining experience, making it suitable for special occasions.
As we navigate through the eclectic neighborhoods of New York City, it becomes clear that tomatillos serve an essential role in the culinary landscape. Each establishment featured provides not only unique interpretations of this fascinating ingredient but also a deeper connection to Mexican culture. This vibrant city is home to a diverse array of eateries where tomatillos flourish, inviting you to explore their tantalizing potential and enriching your taste buds with a splash of the unexpected.
