New York City, a sprawling tapestry of culture and creativity, harbors a burgeoning community that thrives on the mystical and arcane. Among the city’s myriad neighborhoods are shops that embody witchcraft, spiritual practices, and the ethereal charm of the occult. These stores are not merely retailers; they are sanctuaries, each adorned with artifacts whispered to have the power to transcend the mundane. Below is an exploration of ten distinctive witchy stores scattered across the city, each with its own unique charm and offerings.
1. Catland
Address: 987 Flushing Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206
Contact: (718) 381-1984
Website: catlandbooks.com
Catland is the embodiment of the eclectic mysticism that thrives in Bushwick. A bookstore and witchcraft supply shop, its shelves brim with tomes on various esoteric practices. From tarot and astrology to herbs and crystals, Catland provides you an evocative portal into the arcane. With regular workshops and events, it fosters a sense of community for those drawn to witchcraft and New Age spirituality.
2. The Mystic Museum
Address: 1504 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221
Contact: (929) 254-3470
Website: themysticmuseum.com
Nestled in the heart of Bushwick, The Mystic Museum doubles as an art gallery and a shop. An exhibition of oddities and spirits, it intrigues visitors with a unique selection of metaphysical tools, artifacts, and even artwork that centers on the mysterious. The dedicated space for psychic readings offers a haunting glimpse into the future through the lens of crystal balls and tarot decks.
3. Enchantments
Address: 424 E 9th St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 979-0993
Website: enchantmentsinc.com
In the spirit of Greenwich Village’s rich history, Enchantments stands out like a beacon for those steeped in the mystique of witchcraft. This witch supply store is adorned with an array of curiosities: candles, incense, and crystals intermingle with unique spell kits, ancient grimoires, and ritual tools. Enchantments also offers apothecary services, crafting custom herbal blends that resonate with an individual’s magical intentions.
4. Moonlight Apothecary
Address: 267 Promenade St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (347) 987-1234
Website: moonlightapothecary.com
Echoing the lyrical quality of its name, Moonlight Apothecary serves as a gentle refuge for seekers of holistic remedies. The soothing ambiance here belies the strength of its offerings—organic teas, herbal remedies, and meticulously crafted skincare products imbued with the energy of natural ingredients. Moonlight’s commitment to personal empowerment through herbalism resonates profoundly with the modern witch.
5. The Hoodwitch
Address: 18 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 555-0198
Website: thehoodwitch.com
An enchanting fusion of witchcraft and contemporary aesthetics, The Hoodwitch represents a celebration of diversity within the spiritual realm. This boutique houses ethically sourced crystals, tarot decks, and jewelry designed for protective energetics. The Hoodwitch fosters an inclusive community, often hosting workshops and events that encourage exploration and celebration of one’s unique spiritual journey.
6. Botanica Estrella
Address: 109 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029
Contact: (212) 534-3354
Website: botanicaestrella.com
Botanica Estrella, a vibrant sanctuary in East Harlem, immerses visitors in the rich traditions of Afro-Caribbean spirituality. Overflowing with colorful candles, ceremonial herbs, and a myriad of religious artifacts, this botanica serves as a vital resource for those seeking to connect with their ancestry and spiritual heritage. Each item is imbued with a sense of reverence and history, making it a treasure trove for the spiritually inclined.
7. The Crone’s Nest
Address: 217 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Contact: (718) 484-2233
Website: thecronesnest.com
Cloaked in the cozy charm of Park Slope, The Crone’s Nest offers an intimate space that celebrates the essence of feminine empowerment through witchcraft. Specializing in handmade goods by local artisans, this shop presents a warm community vibe filled with tools for ritual and self-care. From handmade talismans to powerful spell oils, this store serves as a nurturing ground for all things mystical.
8. Sacred Mysteries
Address: 647 E 11th St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 253-4700
Website: sacredmysteries.com
The enchanting facade of Sacred Mysteries beckons seekers of arcane knowledge within the East Village. This boutique specializes in antiquarian texts and mystic artifacts, making it a haven for those who cherish not only the physical tools of spirituality but also the lore that surrounds them. The atmospheric decor and extensive library contribute to an immersive experience steeped in long-forgotten wisdom.
9. Crystal & Sage
Address: 415 Richmond St, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Contact: (718) 768-1700
Website: crystaland sage.com
Nestled in the heart of Bay Ridge, Crystal & Sage is a sanctuary for anyone looking to elevate their spiritual practice. Famed for its expansive collection of crystals, candles, and divination tools, this store inspires a deep connection with the Earth. The knowledgeable staff offers personalized consultations, enabling each visitor to find the perfect stone or remedy for their spiritual journey.
10. The Witch’s Brew
Address: 2 W 12th St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (646) 833-2530
Website: thewitchsbrew.com
A whimsical café intertwined with metaphysical supplies, The Witch’s Brew melds the olfactory-healing properties of herbal teas with the spiritual allure of witchcraft. Patrons can sip artisanal drinks while perusing a delightful selection of crystals, magical supplies, and spell kits. This enchanting space invites patrons to forge connections over steaming cups and shared experiences, making it as much a gathering place as a retail haven.
In a city characterized by rapid change, these witchy stores serve as tapestry threads, each uniquely woven to contribute to the rich cultural narrative of New York. They offer not just products but experiences that delve into the heart of spirituality, inviting exploration of the unseen and unknowing.







