Scotch bonnet peppers, known for their vibrant color and fiery heat, are essential to a multitude of Caribbean dishes. Their unique flavor profile brings an enticing zest that transforms meals into culinary masterpieces. Are you ready to embark on a zesty culinary adventure? What if you could track down the best Scotch bonnet peppers in New York City neighborhoods, with addresses, contact details, and websites to make your quest easier? Below is a carefully curated list of ten locations where you can find these piquant delights. Each entry is designed to tantalize your taste buds and possibly challenge your cooking skills. Let’s delve into this spice-filled exploration.
1. New York Spice Shop
Address: 179 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 539-0880
Website: www.nyspiceshop.com
If you yearn for a one-stop shop for all your spice needs, New York Spice Shop is the place to be. This gem in the East Village is renowned for its impressive array of spices, including Scotch bonnet peppers. As you explore their selection, consider trying out a new recipe using Scotch bonnets—would you dare to create a spicy hot sauce from scratch?
2. Kalustyan’s
Address: 123 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016
Contact: (212) 685-3451
Website: www.kalustyans.com
Known for its extensive range of international ingredients, Kalustyan’s is a culinary treasure trove. Located in the vibrant neighborhood of Curry Hill, they pride themselves on both quality and variety. Venture in and discover Scotch bonnet peppers among their selection of exotic spices. A personal challenge: can you find all the essential ingredients for a true Jamaican jerk chicken alongside those peppers?
3. The Spice and Tea Exchange
Address: 214 E 42nd St, New York, NY 10017
Contact: (646) 964-2324
Website: www.spiceandtea.com
Step into a world of flavor at The Spice and Tea Exchange, where various spices and specialty teas come together. This charming store offers Scotch bonnet peppers, both dried and fresh—perfect for experimenting in your kitchen. Perhaps you can make a fiery salsa that contrasts beautifully with sweet ingredients. Will you rise to the challenge of perfecting the balance?
4. Whole Foods Market
Address: 95 E 125th St, New York, NY 10035
Contact: (646) 993-1000
Website: www.wholefoodsmarket.com
Whole Foods not only provides a vast selection of organic ingredients but also features a dedicated produce section. Here, Scotch bonnet peppers can be found nestled among other fresh produce, ensuring that you get the best quality for your culinary endeavors. Challenge yourself to try adding these peppers to a classic pasta sauce for an unexpected twist!
5. Union Square Greenmarket
Address: E 17th St & Union Square W, New York, NY 10003
Contact: N/A
Website: www.grownyc.org/unionsquaregreenmarket
The Union Square Greenmarket is a haven for fresh, local produce, and often features vendors selling Scotch bonnet peppers. Each visit brings new flavors and possibilities, making it an exciting destination for culinary enthusiasts. A fun challenge: can you create a dish using only ingredients sourced from the market?
6. Zabar’s
Address: 2245 Broadway, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 787-2000
Website: www.zabars.com
Zabar’s is a classic New York delicatessen renowned for its eclectic range of foods. Among gourmet cheeses and smoked fish, you’ll find Scotch bonnet peppers ready to enhance your next meal. How about a spicy riff on old-fashioned potato salad? Will you accept the challenge and elevate this simple dish?
7. Orange Rainbow
Address: 537 6th Ave, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 242-8300
Website: www.orangerainbow.com
This specialty grocery store caters to a diverse clientele, offering a mix of Caribbean and other international foods. Their stock includes Scotch bonnet peppers, perfect for those looking to spice up their dishes. Can you handle the heat? Try incorporating these peppers into a curry, and share your culinary triumph with friends!
8. Ample Hills Creamery
Address: 623 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Contact: (718) 230-1800
Website: www.amplehills.com
While primarily known for its innovative ice cream flavors, Ample Hills often plays with savory ingredients. Look for seasonal specials featuring Scotch bonnet to tickle your taste buds. Can you envision a pepper-laden sorbet? This could be your daring culinary experiment.
9. The Brooklyn Importing Company
Address: 7014 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11219
Contact: (718) 633-1133
Website: www.brooklynimporting.com
This specialty grocery store offers a plethora of imported Caribbean goods, including fresh Scotch bonnet peppers. Their unique selection will inspire your next cooking project. Are you brave enough to develop your own spicy salsa with these local ingredients?
10. Fairway Market
Address: 2127 Broadway, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 595-1000
Website: www.fairwaymarket.com
At Fairway Market, the assortment of fresh produce includes vibrant Scotch bonnet peppers. The store’s commitment to quality means you’ll find exceptionally fresh items to spice up your meals. With these peppers in your hands, can you create a family recipe that honors your culinary heritage while adding your own fiery twist?
As you explore these vibrant neighborhoods and culinary havens, the challenge is on: can you create memorable dishes that celebrate the boldness of Scotch bonnet peppers? Let the adventure begin!









