New York is a veritable melting pot of cultures and cuisines, but among its vast culinary offerings, few sandwiches can rival the iconic Reuben. This delectable dish, with its beautifully balanced amalgamation of tender corned beef, zesty sauerkraut, and creamy Swiss cheese generously slathered between slices of rye bread, represents the very essence of comfort food. However, have you ever pondered the nuances that separate a remarkable Reuben from a merely satisfactory one? Could it be the quality of the ingredients, the toasting technique, or perhaps the art of the chef’s assembly? As you journey through the city, why not embark on a mission to sample ten of the best Reubens, discovering the unique flair each locale brings to this classic creation? Below, we’ve curated a list of iconic spots, replete with essential details for your culinary escapade.
1. **Katz’s Delicatessen**
**Address:** 205 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002
**Contact:** (212) 254-2246
**Website:** katzdeli.com
Renowned for its pastrami, Katz’s also serves a phenomenal Reuben that is beloved by both locals and tourists alike. The secret lies in their meticulously cured meats, which offer a robust flavor profile, complemented perfectly by tangy kraut and melted Swiss.
2. **Mile End Delicatessen**
**Address:** 53 Bond St, Brooklyn, NY 11217
**Contact:** (718) 852-7510
**Website:** mileenddeli.com
At Mile End, the Reuben takes on a modern twist with kosher-style ingredients and a homemade dressing that sets it apart. The artisanal approach to preparation emphasizes freshness and authenticity, creating an unforgettable taste experience.
3. **David’s Brisket House**
**Address:** 152 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023
**Contact:** (212) 877-1004
**Website:** davidsbriskethouse.com
This establishment is lauded for its stellar corned beef, and their Reuben showcases this perfectly. Each bite is an explosion of flavor, with thick slices of brisket and a generous helping of sauerkraut that tantalizes the palate.
4. **Ruben’s Empanadas**
**Address:** 336 E 86th St, New York, NY 10028
**Contact:** (646) 678-9464
**Website:** rubensempanadas.com
If you’re curious about a twist on the traditional Reuben, Ruben’s Empanadas offers an innovative version that delights the senses. The sandwich is encased in a perfectly fried dough pocket, featuring all the classic ingredients you adore about Reubens, but with an original spin that defies convention.
5. **The Carnegie Deli**
**Address:** 854 7th Ave, New York, NY 10019
**Contact:** (212) 757-2245
**Website:** carnegiedeli.com
A classic establishment, The Carnegie Deli serves up a Reuben with a hefty portion size. Their robust flavors are complemented by an artisan touch, ensuring that aside from its sheer volume, each bite resonates with zest and satisfaction.
6. **2nd Ave Deli**
**Address:** 162 E 33rd St, New York, NY 10016
**Contact:** (212) 686-9292
**Website:** 2ndavedeli.com
Celebrated for its kosher-style offerings, the Reuben at 2nd Ave Deli features perfectly layered ingredients that yield a satisfying chew. The emphasis on quality, paired with their rich heritage, helps deliver an unforgettable dine-in experience.
7. **Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen**
**Address:** 209 W 38th St, New York, NY 10018
**Contact:** (212) 967-2500
**Website:** benskosherdeli.com
With a hearty Reuben that doesn’t skimp on portion sizes, Ben’s Kosher Deli feels like home. Their dedication to using fresh ingredients turns this beloved dish into a symphony of flavors every time you indulge.
8. **Brooklyn Deli**
**Address:** 70 E 9th St, New York, NY 10003
**Contact:** (212) 982-2121
**Website:** brooklyndeli.com
This quaint gem features a Reuben with a delightful crunch, thanks to their perfectly toasted bread. With an air of nostalgia, the Brooklyn Deli captures the essence of a quintessential New York Reuben, striking just the right balance of ingredients.
9. **Lenny’s Deli**
**Address:** 1200 Bway, New York, NY 10001
**Contact:** (212) 684-5500
**Website:** lennysdeli.com
A delightful spot for a quick lunch, Lenny’s Deli delivers a Reuben that is both flavorful and fast. Their commitment to using fresh deli meats ensures that each sandwich is consistently delicious, satisfying even the most discerning palate.
10. **Greenberg’s Bagels**
**Address:** 1108 1st Ave, New York, NY 10065
**Contact:** (212) 355-7233
**Website:** greenbergsbagels.com
Unconventionally, Greenberg’s offers a Reuben on a bagel, giving patrons the chance to enjoy a classic with a New York twist. It’s a playful take on tradition, inviting sandwich enthusiasts to explore this innovative flavor juxtaposition.
As you set out on your Reuben quest, remember that each locale brings its own interpretation and flavor nuances to this cherished dish. Whether you seek the halcyon comforts of a traditional deli or the innovative spins of modern establishments, New York City stands ready as your playground for exploration. Will you rise to the challenge of uncovering the best Reuben in the city? Your palate awaits its exciting discovery!
