Among the myriad of culinary delights nestled within the vibrant boroughs of New York City, peanut butter pie emerges as a beloved and indulgent treat. With its rich, creamy texture and the intoxicating aroma of roasted peanuts, it beckons dessert aficionados from all walks of life. This article explores ten exceptional spots throughout the city where you can savor this delectable pie. Each establishment boasts a unique take on this classic dessert, utilizing innovative ingredients and techniques that showcase the versatility of peanut butter. Here, we delve into specific neighborhoods, providing not just addresses and contact information but also an insight into the distinctive charm of each locale.
1. Joe’s Pizza
Address: 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 366-1182
Website: joespizza.com
Nestled in the heart of Greenwich Village, Joe’s Pizza is renowned primarily for its slices, but dessert seekers will be pleasantly surprised by its velvety peanut butter pie. Crafted with precision, this dessert transcends typical expectations, offering a rich peanut flavor underscored by a buttery crust that beautifully balances the sweetness.
2. Little Pie Company
Address: 420 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 645-7427
Website: littlepiecompany.com
A quintessential gem in Hell’s Kitchen, Little Pie Company specializes in artisanal pies that evoke a sense of nostalgia. Their peanut butter pie is no exception, showcasing layers of fluffy peanut butter mousse enveloped in a graham cracker crust. The use of only the finest ingredients reflects a commitment to quality, making every bite a delightful experience.
3. The Treats Truck
Address: Various Locations
Contact: Check website for schedule
Website: treatstruck.com
For a whimsical take on the classic peanut butter pie, look no further than The Treats Truck. This mobile dessert haven roams the streets of NYC, bringing gourmet treats to the people. Their peanut butter pie is a playful rendition, often featuring seasonal twists that highlight local produce, appealing to the adventurous palate.
4. Magnolia Bakery
Address: 401 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 462-2572
Website: magnoliabakery.com
Famous for its classic American desserts, Magnolia Bakery in the West Village offers a peanut butter pie that captivates with its nostalgic flavor. This establishment artfully combines layers of smooth peanut butter filling and a gooey chocolate topping, serving a slice of comfort that transports diners back to simpler times.
5. Sugar Sweet Sunshine
Address: 126 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (646) 590-1909
Website: sugarsweetsunshine.com
Located on the Lower East Side, Sugar Sweet Sunshine exudes charm and warmth, making it an inviting spot for dessert enthusiasts. Their peanut butter pie is adorned with a cloud-like layer of whipped cream, creating an ethereal experience that leaves patrons yearning for more. Each bite is a harmonious symphony of flavors and textures.
6. Petee’s Pie Company
Address: 60 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Contact: (718) 786-2020
Website: peteespie.com
Brooklyn’s own Petee’s Pie Company elevates the peanut butter pie to new heights with its homemade approach. Infused with bold flavors and a crisp, flaky crust, their version is perfect for those seeking a modern twist on a classic dessert. The passion for craftsmanship is evident in every luscious layer.
7. The Pie Hole
Address: 1034 E 17th St, Los Angeles, CA 90005 (Note: This location is part of a popular chain, not unique to NYC.)
Contact: (213) 228-8463
Website: thepieholela.com
Though primarily based in Los Angeles, The Pie Hole has made its way into the hearts of New Yorkers. Known for its inventive flavor combinations, their peanut butter pie is a fan favorite that brings a taste of the West Coast to the bustling East Coast food scene. The delightful balance of rich peanut butter and creamy chocolate makes for a memorable dessert experience.
8. Butter & Scotch
Address: 818 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
Contact: (718) 638-8820
Website: butterandscotch.com
This unique cocktail and dessert bar in Crown Heights celebrates the art of pie with a decadent take on peanut butter pie. With boozy infusions and a dash of creativity, Butter & Scotch’s version is both indulgent and inventive. Patrons are treated to an intoxicating blend of flavors that embodies the spirit of Brooklyn’s culinary innovation.
9. Amy’s Bread
Address: 250 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 462-4338
Website: amysbread.com
Renowned for artisanal quality, Amy’s Bread offers a peanut butter pie that emphasizes the marriage of simplicity and flavor. With a quintessential New York charm, this establishment showcases its culinary prowess through the use of fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes. Each slice reflects a deep understanding of classic baking principles.
10. Sweet Lady Jane
Address: 36 Market St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 677-6262
Website: sweetladyjane.com
As a final destination for your peanut butter pie pilgrimage, Sweet Lady Jane in the East Village delivers an experience of exquisite taste. With an unwavering dedication to quality, their rendition presents a perfect balance of sweetness and peanut flavor, capped with a glossy chocolate ganache. This locale embodies the essence of a true dessert haven.
In the universe of New York’s culinary offerings, peanut butter pie stands out as a sweet testament to the city’s rich, diverse food culture. Each establishment not only serves this delightful dessert but also encapsulates the essence of their respective neighborhoods—each slice a reflection of the local community’s unique character and heritage. Whether you’re a local or merely visiting, make it a point to embark on a peanut butter pie tasting adventure throughout the city, as each bite brings with it a piece of New York’s vibrant tapestry.
