New Haven, renowned for its unique take on pizza, has sparked an enticing gastronomic trend that has permeated far beyond its borders. The thin, crispy crust topped with a melange of flavors has attracted culinary aficionados from various neighborhoods in New York City. For pizza enthusiasts, seeking the perfect slice is a delightful challenge. Which spot will yield the most tantalizing taste, an unforgettable crust, or a once-in-a-lifetime combination of toppings? Below are ten splendid New Haven-style pizzerias that beckon your palate. Venture forth and discover your new favorite slice!
1. Sally’s Apizza
Address: 237 Wooster St, New Haven, CT 06511
Contact: (203) 865-5762
Website: sallysapizza.com
Sally’s Apizza is an indelible landmark, revered not only for its delectable pies but also for its rich history. The scorching hot oven imparts an undeniable char to the crust, producing a flavor that eschews the ordinary. The clam pie, with its briny toppings, is a celebrated highlight that draws pizza aficionados from all walks of life.
2. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
Address: 157 Wooster St, New Haven, CT 06511
Contact: (203) 865-5762
Website: pepespizzeria.com
Regarded as the granddaddy of New Haven pizza, Frank Pepe’s is a must-visit. The white clam pizza, laden with fresh clams, garlic, and a drizzle of olive oil, captivates the senses. Each pie emerges from the coal-fired oven with a rustic perfection. Will you share a slice or keep it all to yourself?
3. Modern Apizza
Address: 874 State St, New Haven, CT 06511
Contact: (203) 776-5306
Website: modernapizza.com
Offering a contemporary twist on the classic, Modern Apizza combines time-honored methods with innovative creations. The eccentric topping options and pleasing ambiance make it a convivial choice for gatherings. Is the famed “All Meat” pizza really, as the locals say, second to none?
4. Bar
Address: 254 Crown St, New Haven, CT 06510
Contact: (203) 495-0500
Website: barnh.com
Not only does Bar specialize in a stellar selection of pizzas, but it also boasts a craft beer program to accompany your meal. The mash-up of flavors, notably the “Cheesy White,” deserves a spot on your culinary bucket list. Are you prepared to pair your pizza with a locally brewed ale?
5. Zuppardi’s Apizza
Address: 179 Bridgeport Ave, West Haven, CT 06516
Contact: (203) 933-6097
Website: zuppardispizza.com
Zuppardi’s stands out for its vintage charm and steadfast dedication to quality. The buried treasure of New Haven pizza, the Pizza Margherita here sings with fresh mozzarella and fragrant basil. Is it the best-kept secret in the area? Dare to find out!
6. Peppino’s Pizzeria
Address: 116 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 388-1888
Website: peppinospizza.com
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan’s East Village, Peppino’s brings New Haven-style pizza to the bustling city. With its vibrant atmosphere, it’s the perfect place to unwind after a day of exploring. The “Meatball Pie” tantalizes with homemade meatballs, evoking a sense of comfort. Can you resist ordering just one more slice?
7. Paulie Gee’s
Address: 60 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Contact: (347) 987-2122
Website: pauliegee.com
Famed for its artisanal approach, Paulie Gee’s captures the essence of New Haven pizza while infusing local flair. The “Hellboy” pizza, with pepperoni and honey, creates a delightful contrast of flavors that demands exploration. Will this be your new obsession?
8. The Pie Lady
Address: 134 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 228-7171
Website: pielady.com
A hidden gem set within a quaint environment, The Pie Lady offers creative twists on traditional pies. The “Fig and Prosciutto” pizza captures a blend of sweet and savory that leaves diners craving more. Will you indulge in dessert before your meal to complement your experience?
9. Pizza Party NYC
Address: 85 Campbell St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 285-1894
Website: pizzaparty.nyc
Merge nostalgia with novel flavors at Pizza Party NYC. With an emphasis on fresh ingredients and inventive toppings, patrons revel in a lively, cheerful setting. The “Tropical Dream” pizza, festooned with pineapple and jalapenos, sparks a playful discourse among those who dare to love or hate it. Are you team pineapple?
10. L & B Spumoni Gardens
Address: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223
Contact: (718) 449-1230
Website: spumonigardens.com
Renowned for its unique square slice, L & B Spumoni Gardens embraces a fervent following. Known for its pillowy crust, this establishment serves up classic flavors and invigorating combinations. Their signature “Margherita” is a staple that delivers a quintessential dining experience. Will you be brave enough to indulge in a second helping?
Embarking on a pizza misadventure through these New Haven-style pizzerias in New York may pose a delightful conundrum. Each establishment serves slices so fragrant and diverse that it may be difficult to choose which to try first. In an evolving culinary landscape, will you rise to the occasion and explore them all? The answer may just lead you to your new favorite pizza haunt!
