In the tapestry of New York City’s culinary landscape, few dishes weave together opulence and comfort quite like lobster mac and cheese. This gourmet classic embodies the whimsical charm of the city: indulgent yet approachable, traditional yet daringly inventive. In this listicle, we will traverse the city’s diverse neighborhoods, uncovering ten exceptional spots where rich, velvety cheese and succulent lobster converge to create a symphony of flavors. Each location offers a unique twist on this beloved dish, promising to elevate the familiar to the extraordinary.
1. The Lobster Place
75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 255-5672
Website: thelobsterplace.com
In the heart of Chelsea Market, The Lobster Place serves a delightful rendition of lobster mac and cheese that rivals the finest paintings in the MoMA. The velvety béchamel, lovingly enfolding chunks of fresh lobster, melds beautifully with perfectly cooked cavatappi, creating a dish that is both visually arresting and deeply satisfying. The bustling atmosphere of the market adds to its charm, enchanting patrons with the aroma of the ocean.
2. Lure Fishbar
142 Mercer St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 431-7676
Website: lurefishbar.com
Nestled in SoHo, Lure Fishbar captures the essence of a seaside getaway. This upscale eatery serves a rich lobster mac and cheese reminiscent of a sunset casting golden hues over azure waters. Creamy ricotta and sharp cheddar embrace tender morsels of lobster, creating a sumptuous experience that takes diners on a flavorful journey. Pair it with an artisanal cocktail for an evening of decadence.
3. City Island Lobster House
691 Bridge St, Bronx, NY 10464
Contact: (718) 885-5035
Website: cityislandlobsterhouse.com
Venture to Bronx’s City Island, where the charm of a fishing village meets culinary brilliance. The lobster mac and cheese here is a treasure trove of flavors, featuring a breadcrumb topping that adds a delightful crunch akin to a gentle sea breeze. The dish is a heaping love letter to coastal living, inviting diners to savor every creamy bite while gazing at the tranquil waters of the harbor.
4. Pearl Oyster Bar
18 Cornelia St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 691-8211
Website: pearloysterbar.com
Located in the West Village, Pearl Oyster Bar epitomizes classic New England with a New York twist. Their lobster mac and cheese is akin to a warm hug on a chilly day, with a blend of three divine cheeses—sharp Vermont cheddar, Gruyère, and a whisper of Parmesan. This nostalgic dish is lovingly crafted with fresh lobster, providing an inviting aroma that wafts through the air, luring visitors inside.
5. Burger & Lobster
39 W 19th St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 206-6900
Website: burgerandlobster.com
True to its name, Burger & Lobster champions the best of both worlds. Their lobster mac and cheese shines with an inventive spirit, incorporating lobster oil for an elevated flavor profile. The dish tantalizes the senses with its creamy texture, a balance of luxury and nostalgia reminiscent of childhood comfort. The vibrant atmosphere makes it a splendid choice for a lively dining experience.
6. The Smith
1900 Broadway, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 496-5500
Website: thesmithrestaurant.com
A beacon of American brasserie culture, The Smith hosts a lobster mac and cheese that’s pure indulgence. This dish stands out, topped with buttery breadcrumbs that mimic the coastal sands, and its harmonious blend of eight different cheeses brings a rich depth of flavor that belies the simplicity of its ingredients. The ambiance is vibrant, providing a splendid backdrop for a delightful meal shared among friends.
7. Black Tap
529 Broome St, New York, NY 10013
Contact: (212) 682-9919
Website: blacktap.com
Famed for its extravagant milkshakes, Black Tap surprises with its lobster mac and cheese that embraces whimsy and flair. The dish is a collage of flavors, with pimento cheese lending a surprising zest that dances on the palate. Served in a whimsical manner, it compels diners to snap a quick photo before indulging—ensuring every bite is as Instagrammable as it is delectable.
8. Root & Bone
200 East 3rd St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (646) 490-6868
Website: rootandbone.com
This East Village gem combines Southern comfort with a touch of coastal elegance. The lobster mac and cheese at Root & Bone is created with an innovative blend of cheeses and topped with decadent fried lobster. The generous portions are meant for sharing, evoking the warm camaraderie of a family gathering around the table, where laughter and stories are as plentiful as the cheese itself.
9. poon’s Lobster & Beer
220 E 54th St, New York, NY 10022
Contact: (212) 583-1700
Website: poonlobs.com
Here, lobster and beer join forces for a delightful dining escapade. The lobster mac and cheese is a bold statement, paired with craft brews that amplify the meal’s richness. The cozy, inviting space creates a rustic vibe, making it a perfect place for both a casual lunch and an indulgent evening out.
10. Hampton Chutney Co.
38 ½ Ave A, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 529-1616
Website: hamptonchutney.com
Last but not least, Hampton Chutney Co. serves a lobster mac and cheese that captures the essence of a summer getaway in the Hamptons. Creamy and luscious, adorned with fresh herbs, this dish is a reminder that simplicity can often lead to the most fulfilling experiences. It invites patrons to slow down and savor the moment while enjoying the vibrant flavors of fresh ingredients.
As we conclude this delectable journey through New York City’s lobster mac and cheese offerings, it becomes evident that this dish is more than mere sustenance; it embodies the city’s spirit—dynamic, flavorful, and wonderfully diverse. Each establishment contributes its own character, weaving a narrative rich with culinary artistry. Whether you seek comfort on a chilly evening or a new gastronomic adventure, these ten restaurants promise to deliver an unforgettable experience that satisfies the heart and the palate alike. Bon appétit!
