New York City, the concrete jungle where dreams are spun like delicate threads, is a culinary tapestry woven with diverse flavors and cultures. Among its myriad delights, finger sandwiches emerge as miniature masterpieces, capturing the essence of neighborhoods and their unique identities. Each bite encapsulates a story, an experience, and a burst of flavor. Here, we explore ten exceptional finger sandwiches scattered across the various enclaves of the city.
1. The High Tea Finger Sandwich at Lady Mendl’s
Location: 56 Irving Place, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 576-1923
Website: www.ladymendls.com
At Lady Mendl’s, the High Tea finger sandwich is an elegant affair. This classic establishment invites patrons to don their finest attire and enjoy an assortment of dainty delights. The smoked salmon and cream cheese sandwich rests delicately, almost like a whispered secret on the palate. This whimsical experience in Gramercy is reminiscent of a bygone era, where tea time was an art form.
2. Shrimp Salad Sandwich at H & H Bagels
Location: 2239 Broadway, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 873-9400
Website: www.hhbagels.com
Nestled in the Upper West Side, H & H Bagels crafts a shrimp salad finger sandwich that evokes seaside picnics. The plump shrimp, lightly seasoned and nestled between two slices of fresh, chewy bagel, transport you to a sun-drenched afternoon by the ocean. This quintessential New York bagel shop balances simplicity and flavor, making this sandwich a nostalgic bite of home.
3. Cucumber Sandwich at The NoMad Hotel
Location: 1170 Broadway, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (212) 799-1500
Website: www.thenomadhotel.com
In the heart of NoMad, The NoMad Hotel serves a cucumber finger sandwich that is both refreshing and sophisticated. With thinly sliced English cucumbers layered between artisanal bread and a hint of herbed cream cheese, this sandwich is a delightful nod to the British tradition of afternoon tea, embodying both elegance and ease within its crisp and verdant bites.
4. Lobster Roll with a Twist at Luke’s Lobster
Location: 26 S Market St, New York, NY 10038
Contact: (212) 201-8999
Website: www.lukeslobster.com
At Luke’s Lobster in the Financial District, the lobster roll finger sandwich transcends tradition with its fresh, hand-picked lobster mixed with a subtle hint of mayonnaise and lemon, served in a soft roll. Each bite feels like a maritime adventure, linking the urban landscape to coastal revelry. This sandwich becomes a vessel for the sea’s bounty, connecting diners to New England’s shores.
5. Classic Egg Salad Sandwich at E.A.T.
Location: 1064 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10028
Contact: (212) 570-1000
Website: www.eatnyc.com
On the Upper East Side, E.A.T. offers a classic egg salad finger sandwich, crafted with wholesome ingredients that whisper comfort. The creamy blend of eggs, mayonnaise, and fresh herbs spread generously across locally baked bread serves as a reminder of childhood lunches. It’s a nostalgic nod to simpler days, encapsulated in a bite that evokes warmth and familiarity.
6. Chicken Salad Finger Sandwich at The Plaza Hotel
Location: Fifth Ave at Central Park S, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 759-3000
Website: www.theplazany.com
The Plaza Hotel, an icon of luxury, serves a chicken salad finger sandwich that is a luxurious affair. Tender chicken mingles with crisp celery and a hint of grapes, creating a symphonic balance of savory and sweet. With a setting as glamorous as its menu, indulging in this sandwich feels like a rendezvous with royalty, where every detail whispers opulence.
7. Caprese Sandwich at Bleecker Street Pizza
Location: 74 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 505-1100
Website: www.bleeckerstreetpizza.com
In Greenwich Village, Bleecker Street Pizza presents a Caprese sandwich that exudes an Italian summer. Freshly sliced mozzarella, vine-ripened tomatoes, and fragrant basil create a symphony of flavors that dance on the taste buds. This delightful offering feels like a stroll through a Mediterranean market, ripe with vibrant tastes and colors that reflect the neighborhood’s eclectic spirit.
8. Pastrami Finger Sandwich at Katz’s Delicatessen
Location: 205 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 254-2246
Website: www.katzsdelicatessen.com
Katz’s Delicatessen isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a New York institution. The pastrami finger sandwich stands as a testament to the deli’s rich heritage, robust with flavors of spices and savory notes. Each nibble bursts with the character of the Lower East Side, echoing stories of yesteryears through its meaty, mouth-watering layers. This sandwich captures the soul of New York, a melding of culture and culinary excellence.
9. Vegan Avocado Toast Finger Sandwich at The Butcher’s Daughter
Location: 19 Kenmare St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 228-1332
Website: www.thebutchersdaughter.com
In Nolita, The Butcher’s Daughter champions plant-based cuisine with its vegan avocado toast finger sandwich. Creamy avocado, steeped in lemon and chili flakes, is served on artisanal bread, creating a modern classic. This dish exemplifies the vibrant health-conscious evolution of NYC dining, serving as a canvas for vibrant colors and flavors that reflect a new era of culinary artistry.
10. Sweet Cream Cheese and Jam Sandwich at Molly’s Cupcakes
Location: 228 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 260-2500
Website: www.mollyscupcakes.com
To sweeten the journey, Molly’s Cupcakes offers a delightful sweet cream cheese and jam finger sandwich. The combination of tangy cream cheese paired with luscious jamming creates a blissful closure to your culinary adventure. This whimsical treat captures the essence of childhood delights, leaving a lingering sweetness that echoes through the charming streets of the West Village.
In the gastronomic landscape of New York City, each finger sandwich presents not just a meal but an experience – an ode to the vibrant neighborhoods they inhabit. With flavors that span the globe and ingredients that tell tales of local pride, these sandwiches are more than mere bites; they are portals to the soul of the city.
