Are you a cookie connoisseur or merely a casual dessert enthusiast? Either way, have you ever found yourself pondering the delightful yet daunting challenge of sampling the best cookie trays across various neighborhoods in New York City? The Big Apple, known for its vibrant food scene, has a plethora of bakeries that not only serve delectable cookies but also offer inviting cookie trays perfect for any occasion. Below is a curated list of ten outstanding cookie trays, alongside their vital details including addresses, contact information, and websites, enabling you to embark on this sweet adventure.
1. Levain Bakery
Address: 167 West 74th Street, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 874-6080
Website: levainbakery.com
Levain Bakery is a hallmark of NYC baking fame, renowned for its gargantuan, ooey-gooey cookies. Their cookie trays feature an assortment of flavors, including chocolate chip walnut and dark chocolate peanut butter, ensuring there’s something for everyone in your gathering.
2. Milk Bar
Address: 251 East 13th Street, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (646) 360-0010
Website: milkbarstore.com
Famed for its imaginative interpretations of traditional desserts, Milk Bar offers cookie trays that are as visually delightful as they are tasty. The compost cookie—a melange of sweet and salty flavors—should not be overlooked when selecting your tray.
3. Baked
Address: 359 Van Brunt Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 222-0345
Website: bakednyc.com
Baked is a Brooklyn institution that elevates the cookie experience to new heights with their luscious, buttery cookies. Their cookie trays are elegantly arranged, making them ideal for gifts or events, with crowd-pleasers like the classic chocolate chip and the pecan sandy.
4. Schmackary’s
Address: 362 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 352-1030
Website: schmackarys.com
Located in the heart of the theater district, Schmackary’s offers whimsical and inventive cookie trays that are sure to dazzle. Their unique flavors, such as the maple bacon and the Cookie Monster, provide an unforgettable twist on the standard cookie fare.
5. Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop
Address: 727 Manahattan Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11222
Contact: (718) 389-3676
Website: peterpanbakery.com
While predominantly celebrated for their donuts, Peter Pan also crafts extraordinary cookies. Their cookie trays often combine classic flavors with their signature charm, making each bite both nostalgic and innovative.
6. Butter & Scotch
Address: 818 Franklin Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Contact: (718) 408-2055
Website: butterandscotch.com
At Butter & Scotch, indulgence is the name of the game. Known for their boozy desserts, their cookie tray selection reflects this ethos, with plenty of options like bourbon chocolate chip and salted caramel cookies that are bound to impress.
7. Sweet Lady Jane
Address: 49 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 675-0538
Website: sweetladyjane.com
Sweet Lady Jane specializes in artisanal cookies that showcase immaculate pastries and beautiful arrangements. Their cookie trays feature a variety of textures and flavors, from classic shortbread to their signature lemon burst cookies, making for a visually stunning and palate-pleasing offering.
8. Flour Bakery + Café
Address: 114 Brattle Street, Cambridge, MA 02138
Contact: (617) 630-5200
Website: flourbakery.com
Though primarily located in Cambridge, Flour Bakery’s renowned cookie trays are worth the trip for those in New York. Each tray is filled with delectable handmade cookies that balance comfort and gourmet flair, an indulgence that you simply can’t miss regardless of distance.
9. Dough
Address: 448 Lorimer Street, Brooklyn, NY 11206
Contact: (718) 535-2754
Website: doughdoughnuts.com
Well-known for their artisanal donuts, Dough also curates a remarkable cookie tray filled with cookie creations that are often overshadowed by their donuts. Featuring unique flavors like their passionfruit chocolate chip, these trays are an unexpected delight that adds to the fun of cookie sampling.
10. Asian Tofu Bakery
Address: 300 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 777-1800
Website: N/A
Asian Tofu Bakery offers an eclectic cookie tray combining traditional Asian flavors with classic American cookies. Their unique offerings often include matcha, sesame, and red bean varieties, giving a multicultural twist to your cookie experience.
Now that you have a comprehensive guide to ten fabulous cookie trays scattered throughout New York’s vibrant neighborhoods, the question arises: Which tray will you choose, and can you possibly resist the temptation to try them all? Whether you’re hosting a gathering, celebrating an occasion, or indulging yourself, this playful challenge may just lead you on a sweet adventure through one of the city’s most beloved culinary realms. Prepare to savor delightful cookie concoctions and experience the joy they bring during your New York cookie exploration.
