Fall in New York is a genuine spectacle, rich with vibrant foliage, bustling streets, and tantalizing aromas wafting from local shops. One seasonal delicacy that epitomizes this charm is the caramel apple — a simple yet enchanting treat that many have come to adore. Across the diverse neighborhoods of New York City, we’ve curated a list of ten exceptional establishments serving unique versions of this classic confection. Each entry promises to not only satisfy your cravings but also to provide a delightful shift in perspective on this autumnal favorite.
1. The Caramel Apple Co.
Address: 425 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 873-7730
Website: thecaramelappleco.com
Nestled in the Upper West Side, The Caramel Apple Co. is a charming boutique that specializes in hand-crafted caramel apples. Their decadent creations range from classic caramel and nuts to innovative flavor combinations like sea salt and dark chocolate. The intimate setting, adorned with rustic decor, enhances the allure of their exquisite offerings, making it a perfect outing for friends and family.
2. City Bakery
Address: 3 W 18th St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 366-1414
Website: citybakery.com
City Bakery in the Flatiron District is famed for its artisanal twist on everyday sweet treats. Their caramel apple, draped in a layer of rich butterscotch, delivers an unforgettable flavor profile. Renowned for their custom creations, patrons are often left helplessly swooning at the combination of fresh, crisp apples and artisanal caramel. Don’t forget to try their hot chocolate, which rivals the caramel apples in acclaim.
3. Little Pie Company
Address: 420 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 594-1925
Website: littlepiecompany.com
If you’re wandering through Hell’s Kitchen, make a beeline for Little Pie Company. Though this gem is famous for its pies, their caramel apple option dazzles with its blend of creamy caramel and tart apples. Each mouthful is a harmonious explosion of flavors that transports you to an autumn apple orchard, redefining your preconceived notions about this simple indulgence.
4. Pippin Apple Bakery
Address: 315 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 855-2188
Website: pippinapplebakery.com
Located in the heart of Carroll Gardens, Pippin Apple Bakery offers a delightful array of baked goods, including a standout caramel apple. The fusion of locally sourced ingredients and artisanal craftsmanship creates an experience worth savoring. With a Zen-like ambiance, you can enjoy your caramel apple alongside their famed pumpkin spice latte, allowing for a cozy seasonal experience.
5. Sweet Shop NYC
Address: 607 E 8th St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 777-9080
Website: sweetshopnyc.com
In the Lower East Side, Sweet Shop NYC creates artisanal candies and confections that are nothing short of enchanting. Their caramel apple is embellished with gourmet toppings, from crushed cookies to sprinkles, providing visual splendor and an array of textures. This candy haven is an Instagrammable hotspot, beckoning you to dive headfirst into nostalgia.
6. Hess’ Apples
Address: 56-17 48th St, Maspeth, NY 11378
Contact: (718) 326-2273
Website: hessapples.com
As an iconic apple farm in Maspeth, Hess’ Apples serves freshly harvested apples transformed into caramel works of art. Their uniquely flavored caramel, infused with hints of vanilla and spice, will awaken your taste buds like never before. A visit here offers both a delicious treat and the picturesque backdrop of an authentic apple farm experience.
7. Milk Bar
Address: 251 E 13th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (646) 490-2724
Website: milkbarstore.com
Milk Bar, the brainchild of culinary innovator Christina Tosi, offers a whimsical twist on the traditional caramel apple. Their caramel apple pie truffle is a playful amalgamation of flavors that surprises and delights, showcasing the limitless creativity of this beloved bakery. While you’re there, sample the additional treats to truly indulge your senses.
8. Your Local Farmers Market
Address: Varies by location throughout NYC
Contact: Varies per market
Website: grownyc.org/markets
Among the myriad local farmers’ markets scattered throughout the city, you will often discover vendors selling freshly crafted caramel apples. The rustic charm of these markets and the interaction with local farmers creates an experience that transcends mere shopping, inviting a deeper connection with the land and its offerings. These artisanal caramel apples, coupled with the thrill of discovering local produce, redefine what it means to enjoy seasonal treats.
9. Oฝ่ายค้านแป๋ง Мини折ашок
Address: 45-07 Greenpoint Ave, Sunnyside, NY 11104
Contact: (718) 937-8816
Website: sunnycaramelapples.com
Tucked away in the lively neighborhood of Sunnyside, Oфั้งแป๋ง Мини折ашок is a delightful haven for those craving something extraordinary. Their signature caramel apples boast locally sourced ingredients and a slew of inventive toppings that evoke curiosity and anticipation. The exquisite presentation paired with bold flavors elevates the humble caramel apple into a sophisticated treat.
10. The Great Pumpkin Farm
Address: 55 W 65th St, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 721-1606
Website: greatpumpkinfarm.com
In Central Park, The Great Pumpkin Farm is a seasonal pop-up that brings the whimsy of fall to life. Their signature caramel apple, drizzled with white chocolate and sprinkled with festive candy, embodies the playful spirit of autumn. A visit here is a delightful experience that melds the charm of the park with delectable offerings, perfect for families and adventurers alike.
The quest for the perfect caramel apple across New York City’s neighborhoods is more than just a culinary journey; it’s an exploration of the city’s vibrant culture and artistry. Each location introduces a unique spin on the traditional treat, ensuring that every bite provides an adventure of taste and texture. So, as the leaves change and the air grows crisp, make it a goal to discover these local treasures, one caramel-coated apple at a time. Each visit not only tantalizes your palate but invites you to rethink and experience this classic confection in a wholly novel light.
