New York City, a dazzling tapestry of culture, art, and, perhaps most irresistibly, culinary delights, is home to some of the most decadent desserts imaginable. Among these sweet treasures is the iconic Buckeye Brownie—a delightful fusion of rich chocolate and creamy peanut butter, named after the famous Buckeye tree. As we traverse the bustling neighborhoods of NYC, prepare for a journey of tantalizing flavors and mouthwatering indulgences. Are you brave enough to taste your way through the city’s best Buckeye Brownies? Let’s discover ten extraordinary spots to satisfy your sweet tooth!
1. Fat Witch Bakery
Location: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 929-2580
Website: fatwitch.com
Nestled in the heart of Chelsea Market, Fat Witch Bakery has garnered a devoted following for its delightfully fudgy brownies. Their Buckeye Brownie combines a luscious layer of chocolate with a velvety peanut butter topping, creating the perfect harmony of flavors. What’s stopping you from indulging in this chocolatey masterpiece this weekend?
2. Baked
Location: 359 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 222-0345
Website: bakednyc.com
Baked stands as a bakery beacon in Red Hook, offering extraordinary baked goods that reflect a dedication to quality. Their Buckeye Brownie is no exception, featuring a decadent, chewy brownie base topped with a scrumptious peanut butter frosting. Can you resist the urge to share this tantalizing treat with a friend, or will you keep it all to yourself?
3. Wilhelmina’s Bakery
Location: 225 W 79th St, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (646) 576-1300
Website: wilhelminasbakery.com
Wilhelmina’s Bakery, hidden in the charming Upper West Side, boasts an array of artisanal pastries, including their sought-after Buckeye Brownies. Rich, fudgy, and topped with a buttery-peanut butter layer, these brownies are the perfect balance of sweetness and richness. Can you taste the love that goes into each bite?
4. The Brownie Bar
Location: 310 E 3rd St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (646) 693-5510
Website: browniebar.com
This boutique establishment specializes in an array of brownie varieties, but the Buckeye Brownie shines brightest. With an indulgent center and a sumptuous peanut butter icing, it moves beyond a mere treat and transcends into an experience. Will you take on the challenge of sampling their entire menu for the ultimate brownie showdown?
5. Little Cupcake Bakeshop
Location: 30 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 219-2253
Website: littlecupcakebakeshop.com
This quaint bakery in Nolita is beloved for its cozy vibe and sweet offerings. Their Buckeye Brownie is a delightful concoction that exudes both sophistication and comfort. With a distinct melting chocolate taste accompanied by a buttery peanut butter swirl, can you single out just one favorite from their diverse menu, or will you succumb to the allure of variety?
6. Greenpoint Beer & Ale Co.
Location: 7 N 15th St, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Contact: (718) 389-1115
Website: greenpointbeer.com
Known primarily for their craft beer, this Greenpoint gem surprisingly offers a formidable Buckeye Brownie that pairs perfectly with their brews. Moist, with a deeply rich flavor enhanced by the addition of silky peanut butter, it’s a dessert that could redefine your expectations. How many can you actually enjoy after a few pints?
7. Bareburger
Location: Multiple Locations
Contact: Varies by location
Website: bareburger.com
While primarily known for their burgers, Bareburger also offers a signature Buckeye Brownie that’s hard to resist. Dense and chocolatey with a dollop of peanut butter, this dessert is perfect if you’re looking for a sweet finish to a savory meal. Do you dare to try their brownie challenge and finish it in record time?
8. The Sweet Life Bakery
Location: 125 S 6th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249
Contact: (347) 294-1003
Website: thesweetlifebakery.com
Situated in Williamsburg, The Sweet Life Bakery is dedicated to delivering joy through their delectable treats. Their Buckeye Brownie is a standout, featuring a chewy texture complemented by a creamy topping. How many different flavors will you try before you discover your new favorite brownie?
9. Magnolia Bakery
Location: 401 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 462-2572
Website: magnoliabakery.com
Famous for its charming atmosphere and delectable sweets, Magnolia Bakery has crafted a flawless Buckeye Brownie. The rich chocolate brownie mingles harmoniously with whipped peanut butter frosting, offering a taste of nostalgia. What’s more satisfying: the taste of this delicacy or lingering in the charming ambiance of the bakery?
10. Eileen’s Special Cheesecake
Location: 17 Cleveland Pl, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 966-5585
Website: eilenescheesecake.com
While renowned for their cheesecakes, Eileen’s also crafts a Buckeye Brownie that is not to be overlooked. This dessert packs a chocolatey punch paired with creamy peanut butter layers, combining the best of both worlds. Will you brave the challenge of deciding between their cakes and brownies, or will the Buckeye Brownie steal your heart?
Each of these ten locations showcases the Buckeye Brownie in its own unique light, inviting sweet enthusiasts to experience the playful rivalry of taste and texture. With so many options at your fingertips, which one will you conquer first in your delectable brownie quest? Embarking on this adventure will undoubtedly tease your palate, celebrating the harmonious duo of chocolate and peanut butter throughout the enchanting neighborhoods of New York City!
