New York City is a culinary haven, renowned not only for its iconic pizza and bagels but also for its brunch culture. Among the brunch staples, the Bloody Mary stands out, acclaimed for its robust flavors and tantalizing potential for customization. This savory cocktail is more than just a drink; it’s a bona fide experience, often showcasing local ingredients and innovative twists. For aficionados and casual imbibers alike, here’s a curated list of ten exceptional Bloody Marys scattered throughout the diverse neighborhoods of New York City.
1. The Spotted Pig
Address: 314 W 11th St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 620-0393
Website: thespottedpig.com
Nestled in the heart of the West Village, The Spotted Pig combines British gastropub charm with American culinary prowess. Their Bloody Mary, with house-made mix and garnished with a crispy bacon strip, is a must-try. It’s an indulgent embrace of flavors that beckons patrons to linger over brunch.
2. The Highliner
Address: 210 S. 26th St, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (212) 716-1186
Website: thehighlinernyc.com
In the Chelsea neighborhood, The Highliner offers a vibrant waterfront setting. Their rendition of the Bloody Mary is an experience unto itself, featuring unique additions like pickled green beans and a hint of jalapeño. This cocktail reflects the establishment’s commitment to fresh, local ingredients.
3. Brunchery
Address: 310 E 6th St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (646) 569-2323
Website: bruncherynyc.com
Located in the East Village, Brunchery has gained a cult following for its eclectic menu. Its Bloody Mary, spiced to perfection and served with flavored vodka options, caters to those looking to customize their experience. The playful atmosphere adds a layer of enjoyment to this delightful drink.
4. Clover Club
Address: 210 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 834-8840
Website: cloverclubny.com
A treasure of Cobble Hill, Clover Club is known for its creative cocktails and vintage ambiance. Their Bloody Mary incorporates a clever blend of spices alongside artisanal garnishes, including pickled vegetables and shrimp. This classic drink embodies the bar’s ethos of sophistication and attention to detail.
5. The Smith
Address: 55 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 420-9800
Website: thesmithrestaurant.com
With several locations throughout the city, The Smith is a staple for brunch enthusiasts. Their famous Bloody Mary, made with premium vodka, features a spicy blend enhanced by their proprietary mix. The convivial atmosphere and rustic decor complement the experience, making it a premier destination.
6. Employees Only
Address: 510 Hudson St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 242-4224
Website: employeesonlynyc.com
Situated in the West Village, Employees Only is a cocktail lounge notable for its speakeasy aesthetic. Their Bloody Mary showcases a thoughtful balance of heat and umami, featuring house-made mixes that are artfully prepared. This establishment’s atmosphere is as intoxicating as its libations.
7. The Dead Rabbit
Address: 30 Water St, New York, NY 10004
Contact: (646) 422-7906
Website: deadrabbitnyc.com
Renowned for its Irish-American influence, The Dead Rabbit on Water Street serves an outstanding Bloody Mary. Infused with a homemade blend of horseradish and hot sauce, it features a variety of garnishes that elevate the experience. The bar’s atmosphere, merging old-world charm and modern flair, enhances its appeal.
8. The Brooklyn Diner
Address: 37 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 265-8200
Website: brooklyndiner.com
In the bustling heart of Midtown, The Brooklyn Diner offers a nostalgic take on American classics. Their version of the Bloody Mary is infused with traditional spices and a twist of lemon, served with a hearty garnish that captures the essence of diner cuisine. Its vibrant energy makes it a fulfilling brunch spot.
9. Ainslie
Address: 76 Ainslie St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 486-1900
Website: ainsliebk.com
Ainslie in Williamsburg boasts a rustic charm with a solid brunch offering. Their Bloody Mary, distinguished by the addition of smoked paprika and unique house garnishes, captivates the palate. The warm ambiance of this establishment fosters conversations and community, enhancing the experience.
10. PDT (Please Don’t Tell)
Address: 113 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 614-0386
Website: pdtnyc.com
Hidden behind a vintage phone booth, PDT is the epitome of a speakeasy. Their take on the Bloody Mary is both bold and adventurous, as it integrates a variety of bitters and unique condiments. This dedication to craft and creativity truly embodies the spirit of New York City innovation in cocktail culture.
Each of these establishments presents its own distinctive approach to the classic Bloody Mary, making them destinations not just for a drink, but for an experience that reflects the character of their neighborhoods. The variety, creativity, and culture behind these cocktails underscore a broader fascination with the art of balance, flavor, and community that defines New York City’s culinary landscape.
