New York City is a tapestry of cultures, each thread contributing to the vibrant culinary scene. Among the myriad of offerings, tamales—those delightful parcels of masa filled with various fillings—stand out as a testament to the city’s diverse gastronomic landscape. Here, we explore ten of the best tamales across different neighborhoods, showcasing not just their exceptional flavor, but the stories behind these beloved dishes.
1. Los Tacos No. 1
Address: 229 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (212) 256-9978
Website: lostacos1.com
Nestled in the bustling Theater District, Los Tacos No. 1 is renowned for its authentic Mexican street food. The tamales here exhibit a perfect balance of texture and flavor. Sourced from family recipes, each tamale reflects traditional methods that preserve the age-old culinary ways of Mexico. Special attention to ingredients ensures that flavor is never compromised, making this spot a must-visit for tamale enthusiasts.
2. La Newyorkina
Address: 283 E 8th St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (646) 861-5352
Website: lanewyorkina.com
Located in the East Village, La Newyorkina is celebrated for its artisanal approach to Mexican cuisine. Their tamales are a delightful fusion of traditional and contemporary flavors, often reflecting seasonal ingredients. The vibrant atmosphere and excellent service complement the experience, making it a perfect stop for those looking to delve deeper into the tamale tradition.
3. Empanada Mama
Address: 765 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 315-1000
Website: empanadamama.com
While primarily known for their empanadas, Empanada Mama presents an impressive selection of tamales that surprises many. The tamales served here are unique, often combining unexpected fillings such as BBQ pulled pork or jalapeño cheddar. This inventive twist draws both locals and tourists, making it a popular spot in the Hell’s Kitchen neighborhood.
4. Mercado 32
Address: 1765 E 100th St, New York, NY 10029
Contact: (212) 828-0960
Website: mercado32.com
Located in East Harlem, Mercado 32 offers a glimpse into the culinary traditions of Mexican culture. Their tamales, made from heirloom corn, are wrapped in corn husks that enhance their flavor. The use of organic and locally-sourced ingredients speaks volumes about the dedication to authenticity and sustainability, creating a strong bond between food and community.
5. La Isla
Address: 1557 St. Nicholas Ave, New York, NY 10040
Contact: (212) 569-5985
Website: laislarestaurant.com
Situated in Washington Heights, La Isla delivers a delightful selection of tamales that resonate with the flavors of Puerto Rican cuisine. Known for their savory fillings and soft masa, the tamales are a staple on the menu and embody the spirit of warmth and hospitality associated with the island’s culinary heritage.
6. Tortilleria Nixtamal
Address: 104-05 47th Ave, Corona, NY 11368
Contact: (718) 699-3006
Website: tortillerianixtamal.com
Renowned for its fresh tortillas made from nixtamalized corn, Tortilleria Nixtamal prepares tamales that are nothing short of exceptional. The carefully crafted tamales, filled with traditional fillings like masa and meats or vegetarian options, embody the essence of Mexican culinary traditions. Their commitment to using traditional methods makes this spot a favorite among tamale purists.
7. Puebla Mexican Cuisine
Address: 213 S 35th St, Brooklyn, NY 11232
Contact: (718) 965-9700
Website: pueblamex.com
Situated in Sunset Park, Puebla Mexican Cuisine serves up tamales that are deeply rooted in tradition. Their array of fillings, from classic green chili to sweet pineapple, showcases the culinary versatility of the tamale. The cozy environment of the restaurant invites patrons to enjoy a comforting meal, making it a neighborhood gem.
8. Casa Oaxaca
Address: 1553 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10128
Contact: (212) 879-6600
Website: casaoaxaca.com
In the Upper East Side, Casa Oaxaca presents dishes inspired by the cuisine of Oaxaca, Mexico. Their tamales, filled with rich moles and spicy chicken, offer a unique twist that sets them apart. The elegant yet relaxed atmosphere, combined with their dedication to authentic cooking methods, draws patrons from all over the city.
9. La Cocina
Address: 431 E 149th St, Bronx, NY 10455
Contact: (718) 585-7220
Website: lacocinany.com
This small eatery in the Bronx serves up tamales that showcase the culinary traditions of Central America. La Cocina’s offerings are homemade with the utmost care, incorporating fresh ingredients that sing of flavor and authenticity. The cozy, family-friendly environment coupled with delicious tamales has made it a beloved local haunt.
10. Taco Mix
Address: 100-02 Roosevelt Ave, Queens, NY 11368
Contact: (718) 507-6400
The Queens-based Taco Mix is not just any taco joint; it is a treasure trove of traditional Mexican street food. Their tamales, particularly the mole variety, have gained acclaim for their robust flavor profiles and traditional preparation. Infused with the spirit of Mexico, this establishment is a delightful spot for those exploring the diverse culinary landscape of New York City.
In the sprawling metropolis of New York, tamales serve as a flavorful bridge connecting various cultures. Each establishment on this list contributes to the narrative of what makes our city’s culinary world so rich and diverse. Whether indulging in a traditionally prepared tamale or a unique variation, the experience is one that lingers long after the last bite.
