New York City, often hailed as a culinary paradise, boasts a vibrant tapestry of flavors that reflects its multicultural populace. Among its multitude of gastronomic offerings, the sub sandwich stands out as a quintessential staple, characterized by its delightful amalgamation of fresh ingredients nestled between bread. This listicle highlights ten of the best sub sandwich shops scattered across the diverse neighborhoods of New York City. Each entry encapsulates not only quality but also the unique charm that these establishments bring to their local communities.
1. Faicco’s Italian Specialties
Address: 260 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 255-4080
Website: faiccos.com
Nestled in the heart of Greenwich Village, Faicco’s Italian Specialties is a venerable establishment revered for its house-made sausages and tantalizing sub sandwiches. The Italian hero, laden with salami, mortadella, provolone, and arugula, epitomizes the robust Italian flavors. Patrons often rave about the fresh, crusty bread that perfectly encases the mouthwatering ingredients, resulting in a joyful eating experience that celebrates both tradition and innovation.
2. Lenny’s Deli
Address: 850 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10017
Contact: (212) 421-6550
Website: lennysdeli.com
Lenny’s Deli, a quintessential deli situated in Midtown Manhattan, is known for its gigantic subs that have become a staple for locals and tourists alike. Their turkey and avocado sub, layered with fresh veggies and a generous helping of mayo, is especially popular. The ambiance blends nostalgia with modernity, offering a welcoming space for patrons to revel in their sandwiches while enjoying the city’s bustling rhythm.
3. The Meatball Shop
Address: 64 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (917) 675-6100
Website: themeatballshop.com
Famed for its inventive takes on classic meatball subs, The Meatball Shop has become a beloved destination for those craving hearty comfort food. Their signature meatball sub, featuring handcrafted meatballs submerged in a sumptuous marinara sauce, caters to various palates with options ranging from classic beef to inventive vegetarian alternatives. The cozy atmosphere and focus on community make it a cherished local hangout.
4. Di Fara Pizza
Address: 1424 Ave J, Brooklyn, NY 11230
Contact: (718) 258-1367
Website: difarapizza.com
While primarily celebrated for its pizza, Di Fara Pizza also serves a stellar Italian sub that deserves attention. This artisanal sub, adorned with high-quality ingredients, mirrors the same commitment to excellence found in their award-winning pies. The sub’s bread, combined with fresh-cut meats and cheeses, embodies the essence of a true neighborhood favorite, reinforcing the restaurant’s legacy within Brooklyn’s culinary scene.
5. Alidoro
Address: 65 E 1st St, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 777-9830
Website: alidoronyc.com
Alidoro, a quaint Italian sandwich shop in the East Village, has established a reputation for its meticulously crafted subs. Each sandwich is named after a distinguished Italian figure, elevating the dining experience. The “Pugliese,” featuring hearty prosciutto, creamy burrata, and fresh basil, exemplifies the artisanal approach embraced by the shop. The intimate space invites customers to savor the rich tapestry of flavors that each sub offers.
6. Sarabeth’s Bakery
Address: 40 Central Park South, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 826-5959
Website: sarabeths.com
Renowned for its breakfast items and artisanal baked goods, Sarabeth’s Bakery also crafts an exquisite sub. The roasted chicken sandwich, plump with succulent chicken and garnished with vibrant, seasonal vegetables, represents the marriage of freshness and sophistication. This bakery’s relaxed atmosphere, nestled near Central Park, provides a serene escape for those seeking a delightful meal amid the city’s hustle and bustle.
7. Briciola
Address: 200 E 82nd St, New York, NY 10028
Contact: (212) 537-5280
Website: briciolanyc.com
Situated on the Upper East Side, Briciola specializes in authentic Italian fare, including delightfully crafted subs. Their porchetta sub, infused with aromatic herbs and spices, has gained a loyal following. This charming eatery thrives on a passion for quality and authenticity, attracting both discerning locals and visitors eager to indulge in a luscious taste of Italy amidst the urban landscape.
8. Arturo’s Pizza
Address: 106 W Houston St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 475-6200
Website: arturospizza.com
Arturo’s Pizza, located in Greenwich Village, is not merely about pizza; it also offers an unforgettable Italian sub experience. Their Italian Combo, featuring layers of provolone, capicola, and fresh greens, enveloped in a soft, rustic roll, highlights the culinary richness of Italy. The restaurant’s inviting decor and lively ambiance enhance the enjoyment of each flavorful bite.
9. The Subs
Address: 626 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (646) 327-5651
Website: thesubshop.com
A hidden gem on the Upper West Side, The Subs offers a variety of innovative and classic sandwiches that cater to a wide array of tastes. Their “Bahn Mi” sub, blending traditional Vietnamese elements with classic American flavors, has become a signature choice for adventurous diners. The distinct melding of cultures manifests not just in flavors but in the vibrant atmosphere that attracts a diverse clientele.
10. SubCulture
Address: 120 John St, New York, NY 10038
Contact: (917) 256-5255
Website: subculture.nyc
Located in the Financial District, SubCulture provides an eclectic menu featuring both artisanal and classic subs. Their “Spicy Italian,” distinguished by the addition of artisanal hot peppers, captivates the palate and provides a memorable culinary experience. The ambiance reflects a dynamic blend of modernity and tradition, making it an ideal spot for both business lunchers and casual diners.
Exploring New York City’s sub sandwich scene unravels a delightful tapestry of flavors, creativity, and tradition. From Italian specialties to innovative fusion creations, the sub shops listed above encapsulate the essence of their neighborhoods while delivering unparalleled taste. Whether you seek a quick bite or a leisurely meal, these establishments stand as testaments to the city’s flavorful diversity, inviting everyone to partake in its culinary adventure.
