Are you a lobster roll aficionado? Would you dare to embark on a flavorful quest to discover the 10 best lobster rolls scattered throughout the boroughs of New York City? From coastal classics to inventive twists, this guide presents a delectable challenge: can you sample all of these culinary delights and determine your personal favorite?
1. **Lobster Place – Chelsea Market**
Address: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 486-8088
Website: lobsterplace.com
Nestled in the iconic Chelsea Market, Lobster Place serves an enticing take on the traditional lobster roll, featuring fresh, succulent lobster meat bathed in a light, herbaceous mayonnaise. Their meticulous sourcing of seafood guarantees unparalleled freshness. Pair your roll with a side of crispy sea salt fries for a mouthwatering experience.
2. **Luke’s Lobster – East Village**
Address: 242 E 24th St, New York, NY 10010
Contact: (212) 529-4040
Website: lukeslobster.com
Romancing the quintessential Maine lobster roll, Luke’s Lobster showcases a minimally dressed approach that lets the sweet, buttery flavor of the lobster shine through. Served on a toasted New England-style bun, this lobster roll elevates simplicity without sacrificing taste. Don’t neglect the option of their clam chowder—a luxurious pairing!
3. **Red Hook Lobster Pound – Red Hook**
Address: 204 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Contact: (718) 858-7650
Website: redhooklobsterpound.com
This Brooklyn gem offers a jazzy twist on the classic lobster roll, incorporating not just fresh lobster but also an array of delightful toppings. Their Connecticut style—with warmed lobster and melted butter—is a local favorite. The inviting seaside aesthetic transports diners to the coastal waters, making each bite feel like a getaway.
4. **The Clam – West Village**
Address: 420 Hudson St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 255-0500
Website: theclamnyc.com
A hidden pearl in the heart of the West Village, The Clam presents a fascinating blend of rustic charm and culinary avant-garde. Their lobster roll is characterized by a zesty finish of lemon and tarragon mayonnaise, enhancing the fresh lobster’s natural sweetness. A hint of Magic City pata negra will astonish your palate and ignite your senses.
5. **Maine Shack – Upper West Side**
Address: 300 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 787-3000
Website: maineshack.com
Channeling the spirit of coastal Maine, Maine Shack delivers a dreamy lobster roll complete with a creamy, slightly tangy dressing that pays homage to the classic while incorporating modern flair. Be sure to savor their lobster mac and cheese, another standout item perfect for those looking to add a bit of decadence to their meal.
6. **City Kitchen – Hell’s Kitchen**
Address: 701 8th Ave, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (646) 922-1680
Website: citykitchennyc.com
At City Kitchen, various vendors come together, offering a fruitful array of food options. Among them, the lobster roll stands out. This dish features a generous heap of lobster seasoned to perfection that’s served on a toasted bun. Delight in the bustling atmosphere as you indulge in some of the city’s best seafood, along with an eclectic selection of beverages.
7. **Lobster Roll – Montauk**
Address: 1970 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930
Contact: (631) 668-5676
Website: lobsterrollrestaurant.com
A little bit off the beaten path, this iconic establishment captures the essence of summer with their classic lobster roll that encapsulates everything you love about seaside dining. The ambiance is reminiscent of a quintessential beach shack, making each bite feel like a vacation. Don’t forget to complement your meal with their homemade coleslaw.
8. **Ivory Peacock – NoMad**
Address: 1231 Broadway, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (212) 675-2225
Website: ivorypeacock.com
Located in NoMad, Ivory Peacock offers an upscale, whimsically styled lobster roll featuring truffle aioli and crispy shallots. This roll is a splendid example of culinary innovation while respecting traditional flavors. Pair it with a sophisticated cocktail from their curated menu for an exquisite lunch or dinner experience.
9. **Nguyen’s Lobster – Astoria**
Address: 36-01 30th Ave, Astoria, NY 11103
Contact: (718) 626-1668
Website: nguyenslobster.com
A must-visit for adventurous eaters, Nguyen’s Lobster infuses Vietnamese flavors into the classic roll, incorporating a holy trinity of lemongrass, ginger, and chili. The unexpected layering of tastes makes for a unique culinary expedition that tantalizes the senses. Be sure to try their spicy take on the beloved dish.
10. **The Lobster Truck – Various Locations**
Contact: (646) 502-8789
Website: thelobstertruck.com
Bringing the flavor to the streets, The Lobster Truck scours New York’s neighborhoods to deliver fresh lobster rolls with quick service. Each roll is crafted on-site, ensuring freshness and flavor with every bite. Wherever you find them parked, their East Coast-inspired rolls are undeniably delightful. Keep an eye on their social media for current locations!
The challenge has been set. Gather your friends or family and embark on this lobster roll tasting adventure—who will uncover the undisputed champion among New York City’s finest offerings? Whether it’s the traditional flavors that captivate you or the inventive variations that excite your palate, a lobster roll journey in the Big Apple promises to be flavorful and satisfying.
