The allure of cinnamon buns transcends mere sweetness; it encapsulates comfort and nostalgia—elements deeply embedded in New York’s culinary fabric. Across various neighborhoods, each bakery offers its unique twist on this classic pastry, making the exploration an intriguing journey unto itself. Below, discover ten establishments that exemplify the art of cinnamon bun crafting, accompanied by their respective addresses, contact information, and websites.
1. Magnolia Bakery
Address: 401 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 462-2572
Website: magnoliabakery.com
Magnolia Bakery may be renowned for its classic American desserts, yet their cinnamon buns stand out remarkably. With a light dough infused with ample cinnamon and a luscious cream cheese frosting, these buns evoke a wistful sense of comfort through their unmistakably homemade touch.
2. Hot Bread Kitchen
Address: 1590 FDR Dr, New York, NY 10044
Contact: (212) 369-3333
Website: hotbreadkitchen.org
A beacon of community empowerment, Hot Bread Kitchen serves up exquisite cinnamon buns that reflect a fusion of flavors from global baking traditions. The luxuriant filling, coupled with a robust dough, exemplifies their commitment to quality while supporting underrepresented bakers. Cinnamon rolls here symbolize both innovation and tradition.
3. the doughnut project
Address: 219 Ave B, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (646) 590-2505
Website: thedoughnutproject.com
Famed for its creative concoctions, The Doughnut Project brings an avant-garde flair to the cinnamon bun. Their signature “Cinnamon Sugar Doughnut” emulates the essence of a cinnamon bun while adding a doughnut’s whimsical charm. The combination of flavors and textures offers a delightful twist on this classic treat.
4. Balthazar Bakery
Address: 80 Spring St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 965-1414
Website: balthazarbakery.com
Nestled in SoHo, Balthazar Bakery offers a sophisticated interpretation of the cinnamon bun. These pastries boast a flaky, buttery exterior with a sumptuous cinnamon sugar swirl, complemented by a delicate glaze that further elevates the indulgence. The elegant atmosphere of this bakery reflects its commitment to culinary artistry.
5. Sarabeth’s Bakery
Address: 78 Amity St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Contact: (718) 923-2000
Website: sarabethsrestaurants.com
Sarabeth’s Bakery captures the essence of brunch in every luscious cinnamon bun. With a soft texture and an aromatic spice blend, their buns are often the highlight of morning gatherings. The warm, inviting ambiance of the bakery invites patrons to linger, making it an ideal spot for enjoying such comforting treats.
6. Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop
Address: 174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
Contact: (212) 675-5340
Website: eisenbergsnyc.com
Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop, a quintessential diner, surprises with its adroitly crafted cinnamon buns. The traditional recipe emphasizes moistness, achieving a tender crumb while maintaining a rich cinnamon profile. The unpretentious charm of the shop enhances the experience, making it a beloved local haunt.
7. Dough
Address: 448 Lafayette Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205
Contact: (718) 576-2508
Website: doughdoughnuts.com
While primarily known for their artisanal doughnuts, Dough offers a cinnamon bun worth writing home about. Their emphasis on quality ingredients yields a bun that embraces the area’s rich gastronomic culture. With a crispy exterior and a dreamy filling, it provides a greater appreciation of nuanced flavors.
8. Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop
Address: 1321 5th Ave, New York, NY 10026
Contact: (646) 660-7877
Website: littleredkitchenbakeshop.com
Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop prides itself on artisanal baking, and their cinnamon buns do not disappoint. With an emphasis on locally-sourced ingredients, the buns deliver an exceptional balance of sweetness and spice. The friendly atmosphere reflects the warmth and generosity that the bakery embodies.
9. The Cinnamon Snail
Address: Various locations (check website for updates)
Contact: (646) 389-8606
Website: thecinnamonsnail.com
A vegan food truck turned staple, The Cinnamon Snail serves up remarkable cinnamon buns that defy the limits of conventional baking. Their creative toppings and fillings showcase a dedication to innovation. Enjoying one of their buns offers both indulgence and a commitment to sustainable food practices.
10. Bakeri
Address: 155 N 8th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 388-5080
Website: bakeribrooklyn.com
Bakeri embodies the simplicity and honesty of Scandinavian baking traditions. Their cinnamon bun is a straightforward yet delicious offering, featuring a fluffy texture and a subtly spiced filling. The cozy, rustic atmosphere invites patrons to relax and enjoy the culinary journey through Nordic flavors.
Exploring these ten local favorites provides not only a taste of cinnamon bun diversity but also an insight into the neighborhoods that shape New York’s dynamic culinary landscape. Each bakery tells its story through flavors, textures, and a commitment to quality, imparting a uniquely urban twist on this cherished classic.
