When it comes to quintessential American sandwiches, the classic BLT (bacon, lettuce, and tomato) reigns supreme. This seemingly simple combination is a glorious medley of textures and flavors, effortlessly capturing the nuanced charm of a well-constructed dish. In the vibrant tapestry of New York City, a myriad of eateries serve their unique takes on this beloved sandwich. From trendy cafes bustling in hipster enclaves to time-honored diners that have catered to generations, here’s a curated list of the ten best BLTs scattered across various neighborhoods of the city, ensuring a satisfying bite no matter where you find yourself.
1. Katz’s Delicatessen
Address: 205 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (212) 254-2246
Website: katzsdelicatessen.com
Located on the Lower East Side, Katz’s Delicatessen is an iconic institution famous for its monumental pastrami sandwiches. But do not overlook its equally impressive BLT. Crispy, generous slabs of bacon offer a salty contrast to ripe, juicy tomatoes and fresh, crisp lettuce, all snuggly ensconced between thick slices of fresh rye bread. The ambiance exudes a nostalgic aura, drawing in locals and tourists alike.
2. Jacob’s Pickles
Address: 509 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 470-3789
Website: jacobspickles.com
Nestled in the Upper West Side, Jacob’s Pickles celebrates Southern comfort food with a twist. While renowned for its pickles, the BLT garners accolades with its smoky, thick-cut bacon and homemade mayonnaise on freshly baked bread. A unique addition of house-made dill pickles alongside elevates this sandwich, adding a delightful crunch that will leave you longing for more.
3. The Smith
Address: 956 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022
Contact: (212) 353-2000
Website: thesmithrestaurant.com
At The Smith, an upscale brasserie offering American comfort food, the BLT embodies modernity. Crafted with artisanal bacon, heirloom tomatoes, and organic lettuce, this sandwich is elevated to culinary artistry. The combination of textures is a masterpiece, offering both richness and freshness. The inviting atmosphere enhances the experience, making it a perfect spot for brunch or a casual dinner.
4. The Butcher’s Daughter
Address: 19 N Moore St, New York, NY 10013
Contact: (212) 925-2001
Website: thebutchersdaughter.com
A plant-based haven in Tribeca, The Butcher’s Daughter offers a unique vegetarian BLT that caters to health-conscious diners. Featuring coconut bacon alongside fresh greens and tomatoes, this innovative take remains unmissable. The minimalist decor reflects an ethos rooted in sustainability, making it a fantastic choice for eco-conscious food lovers.
5. BLT Steak
Address: 106 E 57th St, New York, NY 10022
Contact: (212) 691-8888
Website: bltsteak.com
As the name suggests, BLT Steak offers a phenomenal BLT within its upscale dining setting. Here, the sandwich is made with house-cured bacon, vine-ripened tomatoes, and locally-sourced lettuce. Each ingredient showcases remarkable quality and flavors, making it a standout option for those afternoons when you desire something lavish yet comforting. Guests appreciate the meticulous attention to detail and impeccable service that elevates each meal.
6. Sarabeth’s
Address: 40 Central Park S, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 826-5959
Website: sarabethsrestaurants.com
With multiple locations, Sarabeth’s is celebrated for its homestyle fare and cozy ambiance. Located near Central Park, their classic BLT is made with smoky bacon, crunchy lettuce, and heirloom tomatoes on a toasted sourdough baguette, accompanied by a side of house-made fries. This establishment draws in those seeking a tranquil spot to relish each delectable bite while soaking in the city’s rhythm.
7. Blue Smoke
Address: 255 Vesey St, New York, NY 10282
Contact: (212) 889-2005
Website: bluesmoke.com
Located in Battery Park City, Blue Smoke offers a Southern barbecue twist on the classic Jewish BLT. With its authentic smoked bacon, fresh greens, and locally-sourced tomatoes, this version stands as a testament to both culinary tradition and innovation. It pairs beautifully with their selection of craft beers for a meal that’s both satisfying and vibrant.
8. Count on Me
Address: 28 N 11th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249
Contact: (718) 388-4770
Website: countonme.com
Brooklynites flock to Count on Me for its relaxed atmosphere and welcoming vibe. The BLT is crafted with thick-cut bacon, crisp iceberg lettuce, and garden-fresh tomatoes, served on bakery-fresh ciabatta. This simple yet profoundly satisfying establishment embraces community spirit, adding to the overall enjoyment of your meal.
9. Diner
Address: 85 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11249
Contact: (718) 486-3077
Website: dinernyc.com
This retro-style eatery located in Williamsburg boasts a beloved BLT that pays homage to classic diners while infusing a contemporary flair. Utilizing fresh and locally sourced ingredients, the thick-cut bacon coupled with heirloom tomatoes creates a delightful juxtaposition of flavors. The vintage decor and bustling vibe of Diner is an experience in itself.
10. Sarabeth’s Central Park South
Address: 40 Central Park S, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 826-5959
Website: sarabethsrestaurants.com
Rounding off our list, Sarabeth’s Central Park South is an institution of elegance and warmth. Their take on the BLT employs an extraordinary blend of luxurious ingredients that surpass conventional expectations. This establishment is perfect for indulging in a leisurely brunch or romantic dinner, where the BLT is accompanied by a selection of delightful wines and homemade pastries.
Whether you’re strolling through the bustling streets of Manhattan or exploring the quaint nooks of Brooklyn, the BLT sandwiches on this list showcase a delightful array of culinary creativity and warmth. Each bite tells a deeper story of the ingredients and dedication that brings this simple sandwich to life, rendering it a classic American staple across neighborhoods. Take the time to savor these delightful renditions of the BLT, and you’ll find that there is much to appreciate beyond the anticipated flavors.
