New York City, a melting pot of diverse cultures and culinary delights, offers an astonishing variety of desserts. Among these, banana cream pie stands as a timeless classic, exhibiting a harmonious blend of sweet, creamy custard, perfectly ripened bananas, and a delectable crust. Whether you are a lifelong aficionado or a curious newcomer, embarking on a gastronomic adventure to discover the city’s finest offerings is a sheer delight. Here, we present ten notable establishments across various neighborhoods in New York City where you can indulge in exceptional banana cream pies.
1. Two Little Red Hens
*Address:* 1652 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028
*Contact:* (212) 535-2290
*Website:* twolittleredhens.com
Nestled on the Upper East Side, Two Little Red Hens is renowned for its charming ambiance and exceptional baked goods. Their banana cream pie showcases a rich custard that strikes the perfect balance of sweetness, layered with fresh bananas and topped with fluffy whipped cream. Expect a slice that not only satiates your sweet tooth but also speaks to the heart of traditional baking.
2. Little Pie Company
*Address:* 420 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
*Contact:* (212) 736-4780
*Website:* littlepiecompany.com
Located in the vibrant Theater District, Little Pie Company is a beacon for pie lovers. Their banana cream pie features a buttery crust that cradles a velvety filling adorned with freshly sliced bananas. Topped with a generous dollop of whipped cream, it is a perfect accompaniment to an evening of Broadway magic.
3. Magnolia Bakery
*Address:* 401 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
*Contact:* (212) 462-2572
*Website:* magnoliabakery.com
A veritable icon in the West Village, Magnolia Bakery is a must-visit for those with a penchant for nostalgic treats. Their banana cream pie is nothing short of legendary, featuring a luscious banana custard, fresh banana slices, and a pillowy topping of cream. Generations of patrons have flocked here to partake in this slice of culinary history.
4. Petee’s Pie Company
*Address:* 168 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
*Contact:* (646) 693-4188
*Website:* petee-spie.com
On the Lower East Side, Petee’s Pie Company stands out with its focus on using organic and locally sourced ingredients. Their banana cream pie offers a refreshing twist, incorporating a homemade graham cracker crust for added texture. With each bite, you will appreciate the heartfelt dedication to authenticity.
5. Brooklyn’s Pie Shop
*Address:* 159 22nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11232
*Contact:* (347) 460-6666
*Website:* brooklynspeeshop.com
Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, this cozy establishment prides itself on artisanal pies, with their banana cream variety being a standout. Bright, bold flavors combine with a rich, creamy texture, resulting in an unforgettable dessert experience. It’s a delightful spot to indulge your cravings with a glass of iced tea.
6. Baked
*Address:* 359 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
*Contact:* (718) 643-2253
*Website:* bakednyc.com
Baked, located in Red Hook, Brooklyn, is the surreptitious darling of the pastry scene. Their banana cream pie combines rich flavors with a hint of sea salt, elevating the dessert to sweet-and-savory perfection. The pie is a beloved staple, making it a great choice for those seeking a unique interpretation of the classic dish.
7. Little Cupcake Bakeshop
*Address:* 30 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
*Contact:* (212) 219-2253
*Website:* littlecupcakebakeshop.com
Located in Soho, this quaint bakeshop captivates visitors with its nostalgic decor and mouthwatering offerings. Their banana cream pie caters to those with a penchant for well-executed classics. The pie presents layers of fresh cream, crunchy crust, and luscious banana goodness, making it a perfect companion for a leisurely afternoon.
8. Empire Cake
*Address:* 188 7th Ave, New York, NY 10011
*Contact:* (212) 242-0995
*Website:* empirecake.com
Tucked away in Chelsea, Empire Cake is lauded for its creative interpretation of traditional dessert fare. Their banana cream pie is an indulgent offering, characterized by a rich, banana-flavored mousse encased in a flaky crust. This whimsical take on the classic will surely pique your interest and delight your taste buds.
9. Four & Twenty Blackbirds
*Address:* 631 Hudson St, New York, NY 10014
*Contact:* (718) 788-4940
*Website:* fourandtwentyblackbirds.com
This artisanal pie shop in Brooklyn is widely acclaimed for its creative pie varieties. Their banana cream pie is uniquely crafted, featuring homemade custard that melds beautifully with bananas. The shop’s commitment to high-quality ingredients results in a pie that is both sumptuous and bursting with flavor.
10. Milk Bar
*Address:* 251 E 13th St, New York, NY 10003
*Contact:* (646) 480-1008
*Website:* milkbarstore.com
Known for its inventive desserts, Milk Bar serves a delightful banana cream pie that re-imagines the classic with a touch of whimsy. Incorporating a unique flavor profile, this pie is vibrant and playful, offering an exhilarating dessert experience that is likely to leave an indelible mark on your culinary adventures.
In conclusion, the charm of banana cream pie in New York City is undeniable. With every establishment offering its interpretation, the variations reflect the city’s dedication to culinary excellence. From the classic rendition to innovative twists, each pie tells a story, beckoning dessert aficionados to explore the multifaceted world of baked confections. If you find yourself navigating the vast streets of New York, be sure to carve out some time to try these ten remarkable banana cream pies that showcase the city’s rich pastry heritage.
