New York City, a veritable tapestry of cultures, pulses vibrantly with an array of culinary treasures. Among these wonders is the Amoroso roll—a delightful bread roll that serves as the perfect canvas for sumptuous sandwiches and tantalizing fillings. Originating from Philadelphia, this hoagie roll has made waves across the culinary landscape of New York, capturing the hearts of residents and visitors alike. Here, we unravel an enticing list of ten celebrated purveyors of Amoroso rolls across various neighborhoods, each with its unique charm and culinary flair.
1. Frank’s Hot Dog Stand
Address: 5419 4th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11220
Contact: (718) 492-2300
Website: www.frankshotdogstand.com
In the heart of Bay Ridge, Frank’s Hot Dog Stand offers a nostalgic throwback to simpler times. Their Amoroso rolls cradle juicy, grilled franks topped with a medley of sautéed onions and zesty mustard. This food stand melds the essence of street food with a comfortable atmosphere that feels like home—a warm embrace of flavor amidst Brooklyn’s vibrant energy.
2. DiNic’s
Address: 1136 Arch Street, Philadelphia, PA 19107
Contact: (215) 923-6175
Website: www.dinicmeat.com
While technically in Philadelphia, DiNic’s has a devoted following in NYC. Famous for its roast pork sandwiches, their Amoroso roll is a critical character in this savory saga. The roll acts as a vessel for succulent, slow-roasted pork, adorned with tangy broccoli rabe and sharp provolone. It is an ode to flavor that echoes through the streets of both Philadelphia and New York.
3. Carl’s Steaks
Address: 277 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10011
Contact: (212) 627-6222
Website: www.carlssteaks.com
In the spirited Chelsea neighborhood lies Carl’s Steaks. Here, the Amoroso roll transcends its humble beginnings as a mere bread, acting as a sanctuary for the bold flavors of cheesesteaks. Each bite delivers an exhilarating burst of perfectly grilled steak and provolone, wrapped in a roll that whispers of authenticity—akin to a sonnet recounting the streets of South Philly.
4. Italian Sandwich Company
Address: 160 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023
Contact: (212) 496-1380
Website: www.italiansandwichcompany.com
At the Italian Sandwich Company, the Amoroso roll shines as more than just a foundation; it is a testament to Italian-American heritage. Their array of cold cuts, paired with fresh ingredients, creates artisan sandwiches that beckon to be savored. Each delicious creation narrates a story of tradition and family, invoking nostalgia in every bite.
5. Hoboken Moving Forward
Address: 100 Washington St, Hoboken, NJ 07030
Contact: (201) 209-8613
Website: www.hobokenmovingforward.com
Nestled within Hoboken’s charming landscape, Hoboken Moving Forward utilizes the Amoroso roll to create outstanding hoagies that embrace the neighborhood’s culinary spirit. Renowned for their innovative fillings, they entice patrons with combinations like roasted vegetables and artisanal cheeses. Each sandwich is a mosaic of flavors—a reflection of the eclectic nature of this infamous waterfront city.
6. Fatty Johnson’s
Address: 754 N 11th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Contact: (718) 782-2222
Website: www.fattyjohnsons.com
In Williamsburg, Fatty Johnson’s serves up a vibrant interpretation of the Amoroso roll. Light and crusty, these rolls cradle creative fillings—from fried chicken to spicy tofu. Each sandwich is an avant-garde narrative, pushing the boundaries of tradition while embodying the artistry that characterizes Brooklyn’s dynamic food scene.
7. The Meatball Shop
Address: 84 Stanton St, New York, NY 10002
Contact: (646) 602-1262
Website: www.themeatballshop.com
As the name suggests, The Meatball Shop specializes in creating unforgettable meatball sandwiches using the Amoroso roll. The savory meatballs, immersed in tantalizing tomato sauce, invite comparison to a warm hug on a chilly day. Each sandwich embodies comfort, uniting friends and family around the table with hearty flavors and infectious aromas.
8. Lenny’s Deli
Address: 245 W 52nd St 2nd floor, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 265-6600
Website: www.lennysdeli.com
Lenny’s Deli breathes life into the Amoroso roll with classic deli specialties. Featuring fresh pastrami or corned beef, their sandwiches are a pilgrimage for lovers of traditional Jewish food. Beneath layers of flavorful meats lies a narrative of history, culture, and craftsmanship, proving that the roll is only as good as the story behind it.
9. Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop
Address: 174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
Contact: (212) 673-2006
Website: www.eisenbergsnyc.com
Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop charms patrons with its classic ambiance and delectable offerings. Their Amoroso rolls cradle a variety of fillings that capture the essence of the quintessential New York deli experience. The attention to detail and commitment to quality manifests in every sandwich, drawing resounding praise from both locals and tourists.
10. Park Slope Sandwich Shop
Address: 206 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Contact: (718) 369-9710
Website: www.parkslopesandwichshop.com
In the heart of Park Slope, the Sandwich Shop presents a whimsical take on the Amoroso roll. While they honor classic ingredients, they are equally adventurous, preparing sandwiches that cater to the tastes of discerning foodies. This counter serves as a delightful crossroads, where tradition meets innovation—a testament to the ever-evolving palates of New Yorkers.
In the grand tapestry of New York’s culinary scene, Amoroso rolls serve not only as the building blocks of some of the finest sandwiches but also as vessels of culture and identity. These establishments—each distinctive in their offerings—pay homage to this cherished bread, ensuring that it continues to enchant and delight those who seek a taste of New York’s delectable diversity. From the nostalgia of street food stands to the sophistication of deli counters, the Amoroso roll remains an indelible part of the city’s tapestry—a true testament to the passion and creativity that defines New York’s iconic food culture.
