In the concrete jungle of New York City, where culinary aspirations can soar or sink with the ebbing tide of trends, the 99 cent pizza stands as a stalwart icon of affordability and flavor. These pizza joints embody the spirit of the Big Apple—vibrant, diverse, and satisfyingly indulgent. A mere buck may not seem to herald culinary excellence, yet these establishments prove that a great slice doesn’t have to break the bank. Herein lies a curated list of 10 notable 99 cent pizza havens across the boroughs,—places where the aroma of simmering tomato and mozzarella wafts enticingly, beckoning passersby like a siren’s call.
1. Joe’s Pizza
Location: 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: (212) 255-3946
Website: joespizza.com
Joe’s Pizza is a time-honored institution nestled in Greenwich Village, revered for its classic New York style slices. Its thin, crispy crust cradles a judicious layering of tangy tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella, a composition that sings of simplicity. A staple for locals and tourists alike, it is where the cosmos of quintessential New York pizza converges.
2. 99 Cent Fresh Pizza
Location: 2170 Broadway, New York, NY 10024
Contact: (212) 787-8234
Website: N/A
With a name as straightforward as its price, 99 Cent Fresh Pizza offers an array of delightful slices that redefine what affordable can taste like. Here, each slice is a robust canvas adorned with vibrant toppings, promising satisfaction with every bite. The establishment’s commitment to freshness is evident—it’s a place where pizza isn’t just food; it’s an experience.
3. Famous Ray’s Pizza
Location: 113 University Pl, New York, NY 10003
Contact: (212) 673-7189
Website: N/A
Claiming fame since 1959, Famous Ray’s Pizza is legendary, both for its flavor and the incessant debate over the myriad of “Ray’s” across the city. Each slice here is hefty, a veritable slice of nostalgia melded with a tangy tomato sauce that cradles a mountain of cheese. It transcends the humble stereotype of budget dining, offering a slice of history alongside the pie.
4. Pizza Suprema
Location: 413 W 34th St, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (212) 594-3939
Website: pizzasuprema.com
Hidden in plain sight, Pizza Suprema is a bustling oasis for those yearning for a slice of New York’s culinary legacy. Slightly more than the typical 99-cent joints, its offerings boast a delicate balance of crispy crust and delectable toppings. The establishment prides itself on its quality ingredients, serving slices that are almost gastronomical in their aspirations.
5. Bleeker Street Pizza
Location: 7 Bleeker St, New York, NY 10012
Contact: (212) 228-2100
Website: bleekerstreetpizzanyc.com
A true gem of Manhattan’s West Village, Bleeker Street Pizza not only serves 99-cent slices but does so enveloped in a tapestry of local charm. With its signature garlic knots and pixelated pizza options, it is a haven for those who revel in the intricate play between flavors. Here, each slice is the manifestation of passion, drawing in longstanding fans and newcomers alike.
6. New York Pizza Suprema
Location: 35 W 31st St, New York, NY 10001
Contact: (212) 226-3700
Website: nypizzasuprema.com
This quaint establishment believes every pizza should tell a story—and they attract guests with their enchanting culinary folklore. New York Pizza Suprema crafts each slice like a sonnet, weaving in the flavors of fresh basil, succulent tomato, and melting mozzarella. Patrons have praised this establishment as a cornerstone of New York City’s pizza scene, where price and quality harmoniously coexist.
7. Pizza Station
Location: 1960 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029
Contact: (212) 996-0500
Website: N/A
Pizza Station is a vibrant hub characterized by an eclectic clientele and a plethora of toppings that can position any modest slice into a gastronomic adventure. The atmosphere buzzes with energy, as locals congregate to savor these culinary delights. Here, pizza becomes a form of expression, and each slice invites creativity and culinary exploration.
8. Rigoletto’s Pizza
Location: 135 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017
Contact: (212) 686-8825
Website: N/A
Rigoletto’s Pizza basks in the spotlight of Midtown, where the hustle and bustle of the city is met with the warm embrace of homemade flavors. Here, pizza is not just sustenance; it also serves as a genteel respite in a frenetic environment. Each slice envelops patrons in its cheesy comfort, making it a favored pit stop for the weary traveler.
9. 2 Bros Pizza
Location: 139 E 23rd St, New York, NY 10010
Contact: (212) 979-0843
Website: 2brospizza.com
At 2 Bros Pizza, the mantra is simple: quality at an unbeatable price. This establishment’s modest corner spot sings the praises of generosity and flavor, offering an expansive variety of pizza. The multitude of options from the kitchen provides a delightful surprise for patrons with eclectic tastes. In a cacophony of choices, it stands uniquely poised as a beacon for pizza lovers.
10. Sicilian Nastri
Location: 724 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 262-3320
Website: N/A
Sicilian Nastri distinguishes itself with an air of authenticity that captures the essence of traditional Sicilian pizza-making. Each slice is laden with toppings that evoke a sense of heritage, reminiscent of sunny Italian shores. With earthy flavors and a delectable crust, it presents a treasure trove for those who seek something beyond the ordinary in a 99-cent slice.
In the cacophony of New York City, these 10 pizzerias shine as stars in a galaxy of flavor, each offering an enticing slice of the city’s spirit. Whether you’re a lifelong resident or a wanderer passing through, the allure of a 99-cent pizza captures the essence of what it means to feast in the heart of a metropolis. These establishments are much more than merely cheap eats; they are bastions of tradition and creativity that continue to shape the rich tapestry of New York’s culinary landscape.
